Date: December 8, 2008
To: All People of Goodwill
From: Dean Rotbart, Jewish Journalist
Topic: Some Crimes Must Never Be Forgiven
For those of you who didn’t get the memo, here it is…
Someplace in your heart, in a tiny crevice that is insulated by layers of love, spirituality and forgiveness, I hope you remember to keep the fires of hate burning. Yes, hate. While time heals wounds, I pray that it never dulls your contempt for terrorists and those who through their willful actions or cowardly inactions facilitate the murder and maiming of innocents.
What emotion, if not hate, will suffice to judge those who planned and executed the massacre of so many innocents in Mumbai, including a Rabbi and his pregnant wife?
Many psychologists will argue that this is wrong. They contend that for mental health’s sake, victims and their family members must unload their anger or be saddled with it a lifetime. Many among the clergy profess that forgiveness is divine.
I will leave it to Hashem to forgive, if it be his will. And as for carrying with us the horror of terrorism for a lifetime, we owe it to those who suffer and die to do no less.
In our generation, it seems even the most heinous of villains now relies upon time and the pure saturation of evil that afflicts the world daily to blur the record. However horrible or wrong yesterday’s attacks, they depend upon the fact that enough fresh blood will be spilled to erode the memories of all but the staunchest among us.
And trying to keep track of whom to hate is, indeed, a daunting undertaking. What follows is my initial 2008 list of people and actions I hope you will join me in hating.
The list is not complete, not prioritized and most certainly not politically correct. But it is heartfelt and I hope in posting it, it will deliver two messages: 1.) There are a watchful few of us who will remember those who perpetrate evil for our entire lifetimes. 2.) Hate, although politically incorrect, is vital to help clearly demarcate the line between good and evil. We must not simply condemn evil, we must hate it enough to bring us to work proactively to destroy it.
My 2008 Short List of People To Remember To Hate:
• Lee C. Bollinger, President of Columbia University and a Member of the Columbia University Board of Trustees
If I don’t remember to hate Bollinger, who will? After an initial outburst of protests against him and the University, the heat is off Bollinger for allowing Iran’s Mahmoud Ahmadinejad to speak on campus on September 24, 2007. While Bollinger, rightfully, should live out the remainder of his life bedecked in shame, he continues to be feted and honored as if he does not share in the past, present and future villainy brought upon innocents by Ahmadinejad.
Lee Bollinger, I hate you.
• Louise Arbour, United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights
Although Arbour’s four-year term at the head of the most duplicitous, fetid, farcical, arm of the morally bankrupt United Nations ended just this past June, people who never knew her have already forgotten her. (Did Yoga Berra coin that phrase?) Those who don’t know Arbour should learn her name just so that they might never forget it. While giving a total pass to such inhumane rights stalwarts as Burma, Cuba, China, Libya, Saudi Arabia and Syria, in 2006 alone Arbour allowed almost half of all the resolutions brought by the UN Human Rights Council to focus on democratic, free speech Israel. By comparison, the Sudan and Darfur received only a blinks’ worth of attention.
Louise Arbour, I hate you.
• Ala Abu Dhaim – East Jerusalem
At 25, Dhaim met his maker and boy I bet he sure was surprised. Rather than the 70 virgins he was anticipating for slaughtering eight students at the Mercaz Harav yeshiva on March 6th, the Almighty undoubtedly sentenced him to a different eternal fate. Death and heavenly retribution, however, should not exculpate Dhaim from the enmity of the living. I do not wish to stain the memories of Dhaim’s victims by mentioning them by name in the same post where his disgraced name appears, but I pledge to them I shall never temper my venom for him nor forget to honor your sacrifices.
Ala Abu Dhaim, I hate you.
• James Earl “Jimmy” Carter – 39th President of the United States of America
“I’ve looked on a lot of women with lust. I’ve committed adultery in my heart many times,” President Carter told Playboy in November 1976. Since then, Carter has blood-lusted in his heart for a world without Israel. Carter’s 2006 book,Palestinian Peace Not Apartheid, is an abomination, all the more so emanating from the keyboard of one who had the privilege of serving in such a high and influential office. Anti-Semitism reeks of evil no matter how much Carter tries to perfume the stench by couching his words or wrapping himself in the flag of “peace.”
Jimmy Carter, I hate you.
• Eddy W. Hartenstein, Publisher; Russ Stanton, Editor; and Sam Zell, Chairman – The Los Angeles Times
In his April 10, 2008 article in The Los Angeles Times, reporter Peter Wallsten notes that a video of the dinner honoring Rashid Khalidi “was obtained by The Times,” but Wallsten makes no mention that the video’s source provided it strictly on the condition that it never be released to the public.
The Times only disclosed its ‘deal’ in October when the tape became an issue in the Presidential election, since according to Wallsten the tape shows then-state Senator Barack Obama speaking of his friendship with Khalidi. Khalidi, now a professor at Columbia University (another reason to hate Lee Bollinger!), is outspoken in his anti-Israel views and has past links to the terrorist PLO and it chief henchman, Yasser Arafat.
Had the video been made public, who knows what it might have revealed about President-Elect Obama and his political sympathies? But the troika of Hartenstein, Stanton, and Zell suppressed the truth. Their actions offend me as a journalist, as a Jew and as an American. We don’t protect terrorists or their sympathizers, not even for political gain.
Bankruptcy is too good for the three of you.
Eddy W. Hartenstein, Russ Stanton and Sam Zell, I hate you.
• Ehud Olmert – Outgoing Prime Minister of the State of Israel
With ‘friends’ like you, who needs to save his loathing for anti-Semites and Jihadists?
You are a disgrace. The pain and suffering you’ve allowed to be inflicted on your own people includes dismantling Gaza, evicting settlers in Hebron, permitting Hezbollah to rearm, failing to protect Sderot, Ashdod and Ashkelon, and trying to appease sinister Syria by negotiating away the Golan Heights only to receive the bones of our brave soldiers. Did I mention your wish to divide Jerusalem?
Olmert was elected a guardian of the Jewish State. For his traitorous betrayal of that trust, history will judge him harshly.
Ehud Olmert, I hate you.
To all persons living or dead who I have not mentioned on this list, I ask patience. If readers of this column will kindly nominate you for inclusion on my updated list, I will always find space for you in the hellfires of my heart.
Now you’ve got The Memo!