COMMENTS

We welcome your feedback. Comments may not exceed 700 characters.

Privacy Policy

Your information will not be shared or sold without your consent. Get all the details.

Terms of Service

JewishJournal.com has rules for its commenting community.Get all the details.

I am a Hindu and I was aghast and shocked at what happened. Still though, what caused hindus to do such a heinous crime? Do you know the reason, because if you did, you would have thought about right and wrong in a different angle.

  Most of the muslims in India spread hate and sow the seeds of distrust by branding non-muslims as “non-believers”. India is truely a multi cultural soceity. Hindus, Christians, Jews, Buddhists, Parsis all live in peace and harmony. Its only a few good muslims who are educated and cultured, the rest send then kids to “madarasas” who are only preached quran. They start learning evil things like jihad, chopping off arms and legs of non-believers instead of going to schools and universities. Did you know that since the muslims invaded India since the 12th century, they have masacarred more than 80 million hindus? The violence against peaceful Indians still continue by terrorist attacks from Pakistan, most of the local muslims in India support Pakistan as they belive Hindus are non-believers and should be killed.

  Now coming back to this article, muslims burned down an entire train filled primarily with Hindus and Christians in the village of Godhra in Gujarat. Men, women and kids died. This is the cause which created a lot of frustrated hindus to act like maniacs, which I call the effect. Though I still condemn what Hindus did, I do wonder what will be the solution to all this and then I realise that muslims cant live and let live.

I am not a Hindu zionist, like the muslims call us, I love peace and I have friends from all religions (a lot of them are Jews and Christians), but, if we dont act against these barbarians and show that we are no longer puppets to be killed by these savage muslims, it creates a balance. Now most of the muslims in India think twice before they kill a non-muslim, the fear which they face is retribution.

  Tell me if what we did was right? If wrong, what is the solution when we Indians cant even live peacefully in our own land?

Cheers,
Sid

Comment by Siddharth on 6/28/09 at 2:39 pm

correct
no riot post godhra in india , as the infidel moslems learnt they have to pay price

Comment by anurag on 7/06/09 at 7:12 am

What a bunch of lies u tell against the Muslims in India Siddharth! Islam came to India mainly through Sufis and Saints, not invaders and there was never any Hindus massacred by Muslims. Stop spreading your twisted version of history, you moron.Why dont u tell people about that mass murderer Narendra Modi who gave direct approval for the killings in 2002?? The killings weren’t a random upwelling of popular rage, but rather akin to an organized pogrom. That is the dirty face of BJP, VHP, Bajrang Dal and Shiv Sena. It is the truth. And let the whole world see the truth and let them spit on the face of dirty preparators of riots against helpless Muslims. It is now believed that Godhra train carnage was also prepared by them. Watch this:
http://www.sepiamutiny.com/sepia/archives/004812.html
Then we will talk about who committed mass murder!

Comment by Sumayya on 7/06/09 at 10:09 pm

@Anurag
We all know how things started that day right ? Remember Burning Train and Muslim Throwing Stones So that al can Burn Insode and Nobody comes out ? Get your Statics right 900 muslims n 600 hindus. anurag you must have forgot Kashmiri Pandits in 1990’s..
Genoside Decreses The population like kashmiri Hindu’s Wiped out
While Muslims population Got Almost double.Dont you See Jews killed everyday by Muslims ?
What i suggest you go to
Remember how Muslims Converted Biggest Church in Turkey to Mosque ? We DARE To Do What Christens and Jews Were Not able to do.. We proud of Being Arya..Being hindu. Anurag People like you make India Worse place on Earth…

Comment by Ram Narayan on 7/01/10 at 9:51 am

Yes, Muslims got what they deserved. Imagine you were in that train with your family. They had dreams, like you and me. All that wiped out because of that violent religion we call Islam.
If Muslims don’t learn how to behave in a place which wasn’t their in the first place, they might face a situation similar to what Jews faced in the Nazi era.

Comment by Ankit on 1/17/11 at 12:42 am

what a bunch of hatefull ppl you are
faith of peace you say, just listen to yourselves twisting the information so you can draw parallels…
what is wrong with a madrasah?
if the indian gov provided education these ppl wont have to go to madrasah anyway
to some of the idiots that spoke here:
- muslims are not killing jews every day, palestinians and jews are fightign for a peice of land…
- about the muslims you say msulims should behave in a palce that is not theirs, where did they come from dumdum? these ppl are converted hindus / indians, so they are home, if you dont like it go to hell…
- about what started the train attack, first of all biggots like you will start any thing, and the following is proof from euronews.net regarding the investigations into what happend:
” A former Supreme Court judge issued a report in 2005 that concluded the fire was an accident and had started inside one of the train’s carriages. But three years later, another investigation commissioned by the state government reported that the attack was a conspiracy.”
- and for the first idiot, they saw the seeds of mistrust by labeling everyone else as a “non beleiver”, that is so cute it is even darling, first of all listen to yourself labeling eveyone else numb scull, second, are you a muslim? if not you are a non believer,
i better stop cuz you ppl are bunch of biggoted losers

Comment by Ahmad Shb. on 3/10/11 at 5:17 pm

Crime and terrorism have no religion!

Comment by Immanis on 3/30/11 at 7:38 pm

Hindu,Sikh,Christian,Buddhist,Jews evry single community on this planet has faced clashes with Islam why ???  Pakistan,Afganistan,Iraq,Iran,Libya,Syria,Chechenya,India,Bangladesh,Eqypt,Israel,Norway never ending list & only one common thing Islam…all they need is the whole world under Islam & all non-muslim women ...

Comment by Rahul on 8/11/11 at 1:10 am

OK dumdum
it is either you are ignorant by choice or you are playing dumb because it suits your need here..

here is the skinny dumdum:
1- there are 1.2 Billion Muslims all over the world, there must be trouble here and there
2- Muslims are hard working people and proud people, it is hard for them to accept injustice, in India for example, the cast system, most of the people are treated like dirt, you cant even come near your masters to serve them!
3- just look at your example dumdum, your own example:
- Afghanistan and Chechnya were occupied and devastated by Russia, and they are still in turmoil
- Norway you idiot was bombed by a Norwegian
- Israel did not exist 65 years ago, it was called Palestine where Muslims Christians and Jews lived together in peace for ever, now the new state of Israel is killing and robbing everyone, people will resists and there so many United Nation’s laws and requests and demands to end the occupation
- Syria was occupied by France that left these crazy Alawite ruling party in power and now the people cant take it any more, they want to live free, is that OK with your highness?
- Algeria was not on our list, was occupied by France that still meddle in their politics, 2 Million Algerians were killed in the revolution to be free, ever heard of that dumdum???

The common this is injustice you idiot, OK?

Comment by Ahmad Shb. on 8/11/11 at 5:07 pm

@above.. I respect ur feelings ahmed. Please do not take offence. Please understnd.. the train burning was no accident.. the first report of accident was rejected by supreme court and finally the people responsible have gotten punished ( to some extent atleast, some of them have been released becuz of lack of evidence).and about the things of muslims not killing hindus.. lakhs of hindus have been killed by muslims in bangladesh in 1971 war which led india to come to rescue. Even in 2001 so many thousands of hindus were massacred there. Jews are mercilessly butchered (daniel Pearl was killed becz he ws a jew) hezbullah is killing jews even aftr creation of israel. During mughal rule and before that( total period is of 650 years when muslims ruled india) millions of hindus were killed during Aurangzeb, jahangir, Babar and by the conquests of ghori, gazni, taimur lame..and others..I hope u have heard of them..Pakistan even now sends terrorists to kill innocent people in mumbai and kashmir. During mumbai taj hotel attack, one muslim couple was left and all others were killed becuz they were not muslims. of course , pakistan does to create disunity bw hindus and muslims but still they are killing every one who does not belong to their religiion. Please do not take any offence. But every one sees these. why is it that people from islam are so much seen with terrorism by leaders from all over the world. see the situation in chechnaya, somalia, iraq,and other places. I am not blaming every one in ur religion, I am blaming the fanatic people who preach such kind of things to evryone.

Comment by unknown.. on 8/18/11 at 4:57 am

let me tel u sid u r a non bliver thats true 4 what u have said.let me tel u dont pok at muslims because what has happend in gujarat was not at all good be ware if these things happen again than no musilam will sit down? u will get back what u do.we muslims ruld the world 4 hundreds of years and stil we can rule it again .have u seen any hindu ruling any contry ???????????leave the world???????????????? so live and dont finger. u people by killing few muslims dont think u are grate. kipe in mind these things are not good 4 our motherland india.and again we will be ruld by sum outer power.like china is looking at us?

Comment by md Masnad khan on 11/08/11 at 7:12 am

If we assumed the train burning was not an accident, let us see the toll (numbers not exact):
60 Hindu dead, the Hindu gov executes 20 Muslims and throw hunreds in jail.
1500 Muslims are killed in clear murders, 20 Hindu executed and 30 go to jail

When people worship Kali cows and mice I don’t expect much from them
Clearly it is the gov that stays in power because of fear and its tactics, the Israel can’t afford peace, and neither can the US, I hope Ron Paul wins, maybe things will change here

Comment by ahmad shb on 2/08/12 at 9:14 pm

Post a Comment

Name:
Email:

Type the word you see below:

Comment:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

About this Blog

Blog Home
About the Blogger(s)
Contact

Blog Archive

• By Month
• Categories

• By Month
• Categories