Jewish Journal

Media: Palin did good, but Biden won big

by Brad A. Greenberg

October 3, 2008 | 12:54 pm

Photo: Reuters

I was incredibly impressed by the woman who took the stage at Washington University last night. She didn’t appear to be the Sarah Palin of that disastrous Katie Couric interview; she didn’t seem to be anybody we had yet seen. And, except for her obnoxious colloquialisms and a few times when she spoke in a circle, I thought Palin cleaned the floor with the knowledgeable yet completely uninspiring Joe Biden.

Boy, was I wrong. I must have been. Maybe you were too. How else could undecided voters and the mass media completely disagree with me?

“Palin Was Fine, But This Debate Was No Contest” is the headline for Time columnist Joe Klein. (Yep, same Joe Klein.) A little bit of his column is after the jump.

She did fine, I suppose.

She was animated and confident. She displayed an ability, for the first time since her convention speech, to repeat with a fair amount of credibility, the formulations that her handlers had given her. You knew she was well prepared when practically the first words out of her mouth were, “Go to a kids’ soccer game…” She had that folksy thing down—although I did notice, watching the squiggly lines down at the bottom of the CNN screen, that when she tried to get cutesy with her folksiness, it didn’t work.


Indeed, Sarah Palin’s high-energy performance in the vice-presidential debate was the most glaring demonstration—since George W. Bush’s performances in 2000—of how little you can get away with knowing and still survive one of these things, especially if the rules limit the cross-examination as severely as they did in this debate. Her relentless opacity was impressive. She refused to answer the questions where she hadn’t been prepped with answers and when Biden pointed out that an early question had been on deregulation not taxes, she flashed: “I may not answer the questions the way you and the moderator want to hear, but I’m gonna talk straight to the American people.”

Talk straight she didn’t, with only a few exceptions. She talked talking points. And when the talking points concerned areas where she didn’t know diddly, she didn’t talk them very convincingly. Indeed, there were times I got the distinct impression that she didn’t understand the points she was talking about (on the vice president’s constitutional powers, for example).

Joe Biden, by contrast, demonstrated a real knowledge of the issues in question. He made several verbal fumbles—it was Syria, not Hizballah, that left Lebanon—and at times he lapsed into legi-speak, even using plague words like “amendments” and “Liheap” (the winter heating oil assistance program for poor people). But his was a solid, informed and restrained performance—although his best moments came near the end of the debate (when much of America had turned to the baseball playoffs or reruns of their favorite sitcoms on cable). He was genuinely moving when he talked about being a single parent after the death of his wife (he almost began to weep, but held it together); in fact, that moment was more real than anything Palin said all night. He also closed with a devastating point: McCain was, sure enough, a maverick on some things, but not on any of the issues that really mattered in this election—and he listed those issues, and where McCain stood on them, to great effect.


The fact that Palin made it through the debate without running off the stage shouting, “I can’t do this!” should not obscure the fact that there was only one person tonight whom anyone with any sense—even John McCain, I imagine—would trust as President. Biden’s performance was strong and, happily, gimmick free. He used no gotcha soundbites, no consultant-driven silliness—a fact driven home by the lameness of Palin’s snark lines like, “Say it ain’t so, Joe” and—pace, Gipper—“There you go again, talking about the past.”

You can read Klein’s column here.

Tracker Pixel for Entry


View our privacy policy and terms of service.




Since launching the blog in 2007, I’ve referred to myself as “a God-fearing Christian with devilishly good Jewish looks.” The description, I’d say, is an accurate one,...

Read more.