The second round of the NFL draft was not 30 minutes old when the phone rang in the Schwartz home on the afternoon of April 27.
The family recognized the Cleveland area code. Mitchell Schwartz, the Cal offensive lineman who was expecting to be drafted, picked up the phone. Then he smiled.
“I’ve never seen such a huge smile,” older brother and current NFL pro Geoff Schwartz said.
With the fifth pick of the second round (37th overall), the Cleveland Browns selected Schwartz.
“The best part was that I didn’t expect to go that high,” Mitchell said on April 29.
The NFL now has two Jewish offensive linemen, from the same family. There are several pairs of brothers in the league, including offensive linemen Matt and Ryan Kalil, but none are Jews. Matt Kalil was taken fourth by Minnesota and will be Geoff’s new teammate. Geoff previously played with Ryan in Carolina.
Although Geoff’s draft experience was less than stellar — he had to wait until the seventh and final round to be chosen — he was pleased at his brother’s good fortune.
It was fortunate because, as father Lee Schwartz said, once one gets past the obvious first-round choices, “t’s really a crapshoot.”
Before the draft, Mitchell traveled to Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Atlanta and Kansas City, and met with team officials. Lee said his son left Atlanta with the impression that if he was still available when the Falcons picked 55th, they would take him. (Atlanta ended up taking another offensive lineman.)
The family knew Cleveland could take him at 37, but they had seen mock drafts that had Mitchell going 58th to the Houston Texans or 63rd to the New York Giants.
Most mock drafts had Matt Kalil going to Minnesota, but Geoff said the addition does not affect his job.
“He plays left tackle; I play right guard,” Geoff said.
So when Mitchell’s name was called, the family whooped it up and hollered and screamed and jumped up and down.
And then came two realizations: First, “The draft was over for us, and we had no reason to watch it,” Geoff said.
Second, the family had planned a celebratory dinner for Saturday, not Friday.
They went out both nights, Mitchell said.