Quantcast

Jewish Journal

 

So, what do Americans really think of Israel?‎

by Shmuel Rosner

May 17, 2012 | 9:03 am

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu during a meeting with President Barack Obama at the UN headquarters in New York, September 2011 (Photo: Reuters)

There’s no reason to disregard the BBC survey that ranked Israel as ‎the third from bottom on the list of most-popular countries. Of ‎course, the survey didn’t rank all countries in the world, and didn’t ‎survey the public in all countries. But it did survey quite a number of ‎them, and for Israel to only be more popular than North Korea, ‎Pakistan and Iran is hardly an achievement. It is also not quite ‎comforting to discover that this survey doesn’t just put Israel in a ‎place in which it does not belong, it is a survey in which China - ‎China - is more popular than the US. Namely, respondents in most ‎countries believe that China has “more positive influence” in the ‎world than the US. ‎

Should one buy into the hype of Israel’s-image-is-going-down-the-‎drain? Yes, if one compares Israel’s ranking today to Israel’s 2011 ‎ranking, and no if one compares Israel’s image today to its 2007 image ‎‎(according to the same BBC survey). Back in 2007, Israel was viewed ‎negatively by 56% of the public surveyed, positively by 17%, and ‎ranked last among all nations, including Iran and North Korea. Today ‎it is 21% positive and 50% negative. Not a cause for celebration, but ‎also not terribly surprising. The BBC poll is becoming an annual ‎humiliation that Israelis will have to learn to live with until the day ‎the numbers change, if they ever do.‎

Have something to say about this? Join the debate at Rosner’s Domain on Facebook

There’s one thing that is quite odd about this survey, though. ‎According to the BBC, 50% of Americans see Israel positively, while ‎‎35% see it negatively. Does this make sense? Take a look at our J-‎Meter tracking of Israel’s favorability in the US (if you’re not yet ‎familiar with the J-Meter, here is your chance). Our detailed index ‎developed by Prof. Camil Fuchs finds that Israel is doing much better ‎than the 50% positive given it by the BBC survey. True, the questions ‎are different – the BBC asks a question that is a little strange: “Please ‎tell me if you think each of the following countries is having a mainly ‎positive or mainly negative influence in the world”, while the polls we ‎track at J-Meter are about “your overall opinion of Israel” and “Israel ‎as an ally” of the US. Still such great differences seem suspicious: our ‎index shows support for Israel is around 70%. That’s 20% higher ‎than the BBC number.‎

And further oddity: According to the BBC survey, “Fifty per cent of ‎Americans have a favourable view of Israel in 2012, and this ‎proportion has increased by seven points. At the same time, the ‎proportion of negative ratings has gone down six points to 35 per ‎cent and, as a result, the US has gone from being divided in 2011 to ‎leaning positive in 2012”. This in fact somewhat correlates with an ‎increase in Israel’s numbers in other polls. For reasons unknown – ‎and this is confirmed even by the relatively negative BBC assessment ‎‎- 2011 was not bad for Israel’s image in the US: Positives went up, ‎negatives down. Take a look at our favorability tracker to see it. ‎

Tracker Pixel for Entry

COMMENTS

We welcome your feedback.

Privacy Policy
Your information will not be shared or sold without your consent. Get all the details.

Terms of Service
JewishJournal.com has rules for its commenting community.Get all the details.

Publication
JewishJournal.com reserves the right to use your comment in our weekly print publication.