Jewish Journal


Alice Walker gets a celebrity pass

by Shmuel Rosner

July 4, 2012 | 9:44 am

Alice Walker holds up a sign at a press conference in front of the "U.S. boat to Gaza" at Perama port near Athens, June 2011. (Photo: Reuters)

There’s a debate going on about Alice Walker’s true motivation behind ‎her decision not to let an Israeli publisher translate her book into ‎Hebrew. ‎

Her logic is quite lopsided:‎

I grew up under American apartheid and this was far worse. ‎Indeed, many South Africans who attended, including Desmond ‎Tutu, felt the Israeli version of these crimes is worse even than what ‎they suffered under the white supremacist regimes that dominated ‎South Africa for so long.‎

But the logic of her interpreters is also problematic. Daniel Gordis ‎compared her to Richard Wagner – I must say that is a both a stretch ‎and a habit that is quite tired. Germany appears in Gordis’ first ‎paragraph, Wagner in the second, “Nazi Germany” further down the ‎article. Heavy ammunition against – well – that is really the question: ‎What’s really the problem with Walker? Elisheva Goldberg, of Open ‎Zion, predictably gives Walker the pass (will we ever see a day in ‎which an Israel critic is also criticized in turn by Open Zion bloggers?) – she’s ‎not an anti-Semitic critic of Israel, Goldberg says. Proof:‎

And there’s more than just a shared heritage of oppression: Walker ‎married (and divorced) a Jewish civil rights lawyer and they ‎became the first legally married interracial couple ever to live in ‎Jackson, Mississippi.  They had a child, a daughter named ‎Rebecca, who still grapples with her black, white, and Jewish ‎identity. The Color Purple—the very novel she refuses to publish in ‎Israel—was first turned into a movie by Steven Spielberg.‎

Yet again, what’s Walker’s problem? Goldberg, naturally, is happy to ‎say there is no problem:‎

Alice Walker is not boycotting Jews. She is not even boycotting ‎Israelis. She is boycotting the government of Israel. ‎

Well, not true. Walker is not boycotting the government; she’s ‎boycotting Israelis – the prospective readers of her book. Believe me, ‎the government doesn’t care (and shouldn’t care) whether Walker’s ‎book is bought by a private Publishing House and translated and is ‎sold to Israeli readers. So Goldberg is wrong to casually treat ‎Walker’s move as a protest against the Israeli government, but she has ‎a point when it comes to her own protestation against Gordis’ casual ‎use of Nazi analogies. As much as I agree with Gordis that Walker’s ‎position is far from acceptable, I think his analysis of her motivation ‎is probably false, and the key sentence leading him to the wrong ‎conclusion is this one:‎

When a person of Walker’s obvious intelligence utters such drivel, ‎what we have is not a matter of ignorance. It is a matter of hate. ‎

This is the basic logic: Walker is intelligent, hence it can not be ‎ignorance that makes her say such things and do such things, hence ‎there must be other reason we should be looking for, hence the most ‎available other-reason is hate. ‎

But what if Gordis’ premise is wrong? What if Walker is not as ‎intelligent as he believes she is? What if writing books about ‎whatever-it-is-she-writes-about doesn’t necessarily make Walker more ‎informed about world affairs than your average Joe? What if writing ‎books make authors even less likely to understand world affairs? ‎Since I work for a publisher, I get to meet with many authors of many ‎books. Almost all of them are quite intelligent, but not all have much ‎to say about political affairs that is worth listening to. And some have ‎strange ideas and radical tendencies. Authors, both in Israel and in the ‎US, get to speak about many things in which they don’t understand ‎‎(much like actors, rock stars and other celebrities). ‎

So - I’ll give Walker a celebrity pass. The pass of ignorance. And if ‎because of her ignorance Israelis will not be able to read The Color ‎Purple in Hebrew – they shall overcome.‎

Have something to say about this? Join the debate at Rosner’s Domain on Facebook

Tracker Pixel for Entry


We welcome your feedback.

Privacy Policy
Your information will not be shared or sold without your consent. Get all the details.

Terms of Service
JewishJournal.com has rules for its commenting community.Get all the details.

JewishJournal.com reserves the right to use your comment in our weekly print publication.


The Israel Factor