Jewish Journal

The Best Laid Plans

by Rabbi Ilana Grinblat

March 19, 2010 | 7:32 pm

This week felt to me like a comedy of errors. My son came down with a cold which he was kind enough to share with me. So on Saturday morning, I woke up with laryngitis. The problem was that I was invited to speak as a guest rabbi – but giving a sermon is a little tricky if you can’t speak! Having laryngitis any other week would be no problem, but the one week I needed to speak, I couldn’t.

On Monday morning, the gas in our house went out; my son Jeremy had apparently inadvertently triggered the earthquake shut off valve with his basketball. My week was filled with these types of minor but annoying problems. There’s a Yiddish expression: “Mann traoch, Gott lauch,” which means ‘man plans, God laughs.’ This week reminded me that God has a great sense of humor.

As I was encountering minor blunders, the Jewish people seemed to be making some errors with potentially major implications. During Biden’s trip to Israel, the Israeli government announced a plan to build new housing in East Jerusalem which caused tension between Israel and the US. Then, at the Western Wall, Orthodox Jews threw chairs at a group of Jewish women who were praying to mark the new month of Nisan. Also, this week a bill was brought before the Israeli Parliament which would have made converts to Judaism living in Israel ineligible for Israeli citizenship. (Thankfully, the bill was tabled for the time being.) Since Passover is celebrated in Nisan, the month is supposed celebrate liberation. Instead, the new month was accompanied with much troubling news.

Indeed, this week’s Torah portion also seems like a list of everything that could possibly go wrong. The portion begins the book of Vayikra (Leviticus) by outlining the instructions for animal sacrifices. God explains to Moses: “If a person sins unwittingly against any of the commandments”… then give this type of offering. Each paragraph begins with a problem or mistake that could be made deliberately or inadvertently, and then stipulates what to do to rectify each situation. All the sacrifices follow this pattern except the Zevach Sh’lamim: (‘the offering of well-being). The word sh’lamim is from the word shalem (meaning whole), which is from the same root as shalom, peace. If by some miracle, everything goes well, then there’s an offering for that too!

Although the system of animal sacrifices is foreign to us, the underlying message of the portion still resonates today. Life is unpredictable, but no matter what happens, there is a way back to God, to ourselves, to the sense of wholeness that we crave.

People often say: “Everything turns out for the best” – which is utterly absurd. The Torah portion is more realistic than that. The parasha recognizes that sometimes things do go terribly awry. Some of our dreams go up in smoke, and we have to make painful sacrifices for all that we achieve. When we err, we need to atone and take difficult steps to amends. But no matter what, there’s a path back to God.

In ways large and small, life has a way of reminding us of all that we can’t control. For some reason, having children heightens the unpredictability of life. Yet it also heightens our sense of wonder when by some miracle, we do feel okay and are able to accomplish something that we planned.

Let’s hope that this Passover ushers in a greater spirit of tolerance and mutual understanding. Through the ups and downs of daily living, despite all the mistakes we make along the way, we can make our lives an offering of wholeness to God.

Tracker Pixel for Entry


View our privacy policy and terms of service.




Rabbi Ilana Grinblat teaches rabbinic literature at the American Jewish University’s Ziegler School of Rabbinic Studies. She lives in Los Angeles with her husband and their...

Read more.