1) We, members of the Los Angeles Jewish community, write to express our anguish and sorrow over the loss of life and scale of destruction in the recent conflict between Israel and Gaza. We condemn Hamas’ war-time tactics, especially its disregard for the residents of Israel, many of whom lived in a state of terror as rockets rained down on them. At the same time, we are acutely aware of the destruction inflicted by Israel in Gaza. In thinking of the violence from this latest conflict, we affirm the ancient wisdom of the Mishnah that “whoever destroys a single life, it is as if s/he destroyed an entire world.” (Sanhedrin 4:5)
2) Hovering above all—above all questions of tactics and strategy—are the dead children, nearly 500 Palestinians and 1 Israeli. The loss of one innocent life is intolerable. The loss of many hundreds of innocent lives demands a moral accounting, alongside any other inquiry that must be conducted into this war. Especially as we enter into the season of Teshuvah, it is imperative that we look into our souls and not rest quiet until we understand how this massive loss of innocent lives could have taken place. We insist that it not happen again.
3) As deeply as we are connected to Israel, we reject the demand often heard in the Jewish community, especially in war-time, that we support Israeli policy without dissent. All too often, criticism of Israel’s policies is treated with incivility. Similarly, we reject the lack of compassion and denial of profound suffering of human beings on the other side of the divide. We believe it is an obligation of all Jews to contribute to humanitarian relief in both Israel and Gaza as a reflection of our commitment to our own people and to the neighbors with whom we must find a way to live together in peace.
4) We urge our friends, colleagues, and, above all, rabbis in the Jewish community to undertake a profound rethinking of the way they manifest “support” for Israel. Unreflective support perpetuates the myopia that leaves too many of us insensitive to the suffering of our Palestinian neighbors and cousins. At the same time, the kind of unreflective support that was on display in the latest Gaza war does not serve Israel’s best interests, but rather reinforces the extremist tendencies that threaten to undermine its democratic core.
5) We are distraught that this is the third cycle of conflict between Israel and Gaza since Israel’s unilateral exit from the settlements in Gaza in 2005. Each conflict brings more destruction and deepens the enmity and frustration between the two sides. We believe that the blockade that Israel has imposed on Gaza since 2007 has contributed to an intolerable economic, health and humanitarian situation for its residents and should be removed, with appropriate supervision to be set in place to ensure that the material brought in be for civilian use only.
6) We call upon Israelis and Palestinians, and especially their leaders, to eschew the all-too-familiar path of violence and opt instead for one based on mutual respect for the rights and dignity of the two peoples.
7) We call on the Jewish community to come together in groups during this season of teshuvah to discuss the war and ways to exit the ongoing cycle of violence—and to do so in a spirit of comity even when differences exist among us.
8) If you are interested in finding a discussion group near you, please contact Jessica Marglin at jmarglin@gmail.com. And if you are interested in signing on to this statement, please add your name by going to the following website: http://www.justice-in-the-city.com/?page_id=694
John Antignas
Rabbi Lewis Barth
Dr. Joan Beerman
Rabbi Leonard Beerman
Rabbi Haim Dov Beliak
Prof. Leah Boustan
Prof. Ra’anan Boustan
Prof. Aryeh Cohen
Georgianne Cutter, LCSW
Prof. William Cutter
Prof. Ellen Dubois
Prof. Reuven Firestone
Prof. Jeffrey Helmreich
Andrea Hodos
Steven J. Kaplan
Rabbi Susan Laemmle
Dr. Lee Lainer
Luis Lainer
Prof. Baruch Link
Teri Cohan Link
Prof. Jessica Marglin
Douglas E. Mirell
Prof. David N. Myers
Rabbi Sanford Ragins
Prof. Hilary Schor
Prof. Dan Simon
Rabbi Ruth Sohn
Prof. Nomi M. Stolzenberg
Prof. Irene Tucker
Prof. Roger Waldinger
Sandy Weiner
Barbara Wettstein
Prof. Howard Wettstein
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.