Jewish Journal


Posted on Feb. 21, 2008 at 5:00 pm

Dr. Amnon Netzer, World-Renowned Iranian Jewish Scholar, Dies at 73

In the academic world of Middle Eastern studies he was considered an intellectual giant for his comprehensive works in the field. To the tight-knit Iranian Jewish community worldwide he was considered a legend who had researched and helped preserve the near 2,500 year history of Iran's Jewry. For his life's work, the death of Dr. Amnon Netzer at the age of 73 on Feb. 15 was a blow to Iranian Jews living in the U.S., Israel and Iran.

Nearly 500 local Dr. Amnon NetzerIranian Jews gathered at the Nessah Synagogue in Beverly Hills on Feb. 17 to honor Netzer whose coffin was draped in the flags of Israel and former Iranian government. The mourners were mostly older Iranian Jews and close friends including Nessah's Rabbi David Shofet. "His life and love was with reading, discovering and sharing the history of Iranian Jews," Shofet said. "He sacrificed his entire life in order to record our community's history and he traveled the world including to the most remote villages in Iran in order to uncover the truth about Iranian Jews."

Netzer was born in the northwestern Iranian city of Rasht in 1934 and immigrated with his family to Israel in 1950. He is credited for working as an editor for various Persian language newspapers in Tel Aviv during the 1950's and as the first producer/anchor of the Persian language news broadcasts on the Voice of Israel radio between 1955 and 1958. After receiving a degree in Middle East and International Affairs from Hebrew University in Jerusalem, in 1965 Netzer obtained a degree from New York's Columbia University in Iranian Studies, Indo-European languages, as well as Semitic Languages and literature. Later in 1969, Netzer obtained his doctoral degree in the same subjects from Columbia and went on to teach at various universities through out his career.

In 1970, Netzer returned to Israel where he co-founded the Iranian Studies department at Hebrew University and began his research on Iranian Jewish history as well as the ancient Judeo-Persian language. He not only authored scores of articles about Iranian Jewish history but helped compile, "Padyavand," a rare and comprehensive three-volume book detailing various significant events in Iranian Jewish history. "In the period of time after the [1979 Iranian] revolution when Iranian Jews were not at all knowledgeable about their history which was not documented, Amnon Netzer was the one who started the process of gathering the documents about our 2,500 history," said George Haroonian, an Iranian Jewish activist. "He woke us up as to our background and roots."

Netzer's colleagues and former students said he was unique because he was one of the world's foremost authorities in a wide range of topics within his field. These included general Iranian history, Persian linguistics, Iranian cultural and literature, Judeo-Persian history, literature, and Judeo-Persian linguistics as well Islamic culture. "In my opinion, Professor Netzer was one of the rare genii that emerges once in a few centuries," said Dr. Nahid Pirnazar, Netzer's mentee and a UCLA professor of Judeo-Persian history. "His knowledge of his field was both comprehensive and diverse. What set him apart was his ability to present the history of Iranian Jewry in the context of solid academic evidence, not his personal feelings or agenda."

While the Iranian Jewish community is still struggling to come to grips with Netzer's passing, his close friends said future generations will undoubtedly benefit from his legacy and knowledge he left behind. "As I have said before and still feel, it will only be in the future that we truly appreciate and understand the depth of Amnon Netzer's work and contributions to his field," Pirnazar said. Netzer's friends said he was also among a small and distinguished panel of academics that were frequently called on by Israeli government officials to share their expertise regarding Iran and the Middle East.

Netzer died at UCLA Medical Center in Los Angeles and his body was returned to Israel for burial after the memorial. He is survived by a wife and two children living in Israel.

-- Karmel Melamed

Lt. Col. Melvin Hanberg, First President of the Jewish Genealogical Society of Los Angeles, Dies at 84

Lt. Col. Melvin Hanberg, whose loss of 17 family members in the Nazi Holocaust stirred him to launch a new approach to Holocaust remembrance by becoming a pioneering Jewish family historian and founder in Los Angeles of the second U.S. Jewish genealogical organization, has died at age 84.

Born in Detroit on May 28, 1923, and raised in Chicago, he settled in Los Angeles in 1947 after service in World War II. Since falling and breaking a leg in 2001, he was living in a skilled nursing facility and died on July 13, 2007.

In 1942, reported mass atrocities against European Jews caused Hanberg to ask the Hebrew Immigrant Lt. Col. Melvin HanbergAid Society (HIAS) about his father's family in the Warsaw Ghetto. HIAS' response that all Jews were in extreme danger led him to volunteer for duty in Europe. Instead, he was sent to the Pacific where, as part of the Army Air Corps Signal Corps, he broke enemy codes and transmitted coded instructions to troops for Gen. Douglas MacArthur's liberation of the Philippines and New Guinea.

Serving with the Army of Occupation in Tokyo for nearly a year following the war, he toured Shanghai, where he met a remnant of European Jews who had found refuge there. In 1948, he completed a degree in Applied Physics at UCLA and became an electronics engineer. He returned to uniform in the Korean War and eventually rose to lieutenant colonel in the Army Reserves.

At World War II's end, he learned that among his many relatives in Europe, only one cousin had survived the Holocaust. At this time, he made it his task to remember the victims and honor a lost civilization by activating the virtually unknown pursuit of Jewish genealogy.He discovered that although Jewish communities were nearly wiped out, the Nazis had carefully preserved vital records. After tracing his family back to the late 1600s, he organized and served as first president of the Jewish Genealogical Society of Los Angeles (JGS-LA) in 1979. At present, that group has more than 800 members and many similar groups exist across the nation.

Flooded with requests, he gladly offered his expertise to hundreds free of charge. He gave David Ben-Gurion's son a copy of his father's birth certificate for use in a biography, documented a non-Jew's relationship to Jefferson Davis and helped a Native American prove he was related to Geronimo.

Hanberg devised the first translation worksheets, still in use, for words appearing on Polish-Jewish documents, including German words. Irreverently, he noted that Polish "zgon" refers to someone who had died, and the phrase "yes, he's z-gon" became one of his many colloquialisms.

A co-founder and first president of the Polish Genealogical Society of California starting in July 1989, he also spoke at numerous family-history conventions, conferences and seminars. For many years he was the staff "Jewish expert" and "Polish expert" at the Latter-Day Saints Family History Center in West Los Angeles. Widely viewed as the leading U.S. Jewish genealogist, he prided himself on almost never being "stumped" by a question on the subject.

In the early 1960s, Hanberg discovered that engineering was a boom-and-bust business, became a real estate broker instead and founded and ran Active Realty in Hawthorne for 40 years. A skilled dealmaker, Hanberg had a reputation for being able to argue real estate law as well as any attorney and had vast knowledge of home and neighborhood values.

The Hawthorne City Council adjourned its Aug. 14, 2007 meeting "in deepest sympathy, in memory and honor of Melvin Hanberg," stated a certificate signed by Mayor Larry Guidi and City Councilmembers Pablo Catano, Ginny McGinnis Lambert and Gary Parsons.

His survivors include his wife Alice, whom he married in 1950; daughter, son and brother.

The family welcomes donations to the Melvin Hanberg Memorial Scholarship Fund, Temple Akiba, 5249 Sepulveda Blvd., Culver City, CA, 90230; (310) 398-5783.

Anne Alexson died Jan. 6 at 83. She is survived by her daughter, Dr. Joyce; and son, Dr. Edward. Malinow and Silverman

David Mark Altshuler died Jan. 20 at 62. He is survived by his mother, Dorothy; brothers, Rabbi Stuart (Ella) and Bruce (Melinda); and companion, Cassie Alexander. Malinow and Silverman

Victor Samuel Cohen died Jan. 17 at 87. He is survived by his wife, Katherine; daughters, Sarah and Marie Altchech; son, Benjamin; and two grandsons. Malinow and Silverman

Dr. Arnold Howard Cooperman died Jan. 15 at 76. He is survived by his wife, Caroline; son, Chad; daughters Karen Hampshire and Deena; and seven grandchildren. Sholom Chapels

Toby Cukier died Jan. 17 at 84. He is survived by his wife, Bridget; daughters, Linda (Terry) Cohen and Rosie (Mark) Jackanich; and four grandchildren. Mount Sinai

Dr. Gordon Eckerling died Jan. 17 at 55. He is survived by his wife, Cheryl; daughters, Samantha, Rachel (Ralph) and Elizabeth (Ian) Crossley; son, Aaron (Kristina); stepdaughter, Nicole Smidt; stepson, David Smidt; mother, Selma; and sisters, Sheri (Bob) Simon and Sally (Neal) Cohen. Malinow and Silverman

Ida Greenbaum died Jan. 4 at 93. She is survived by her daughter, Harriet (Ted) Wolfson; six grandchildren; and 12 great-grandchildren. Sholom Chapels

Faye Hassen died Jan. 13 at 88. She is survived by her son, Bruce Singman; and two grandchildren. Sholom Chapels

Anne Korman Horwitz died Jan. 18 at 96. She is survived by her son, Arlo (Sue) Mark. Malinow and Silverman

Lee Goldstein died Jan. 20 at 89. He is survived by his sister, Beverly Israel; companion, Doris Perry; sister-in-law, Eudice Shapiro; brother-in-law, Heschel (Shirley) Shapiro; nieces and nephews. Mount Sinai

Isidore Gabel died Jan. 18 at 90. He is survived by his wife, Esther Gabel; daughters, Natalie (Oscar) Elbaum, Geri (George) Bauer and Dr. Ellen; seven grandchildren; and six great-grandchildren. Mount Sinai

Michael Heizler died Jan. 19 at 87. He is survived by his stepson, Sasa Neuman; sisters, Suri Danzinger and Pearl Gottfried. Mount Sinai

Lillian Ruth Kantor died Jan. 19 at 103. She is survived by her daughter, Beverly Bass. Malinow and Silverman

Cantor Samuel Kelemer died Jan. 8 at 90. He is survived by his wife, Linda; son, Dov (Sarah); stepson, David (Stacy); three step-grandchildren; nephews; and nieces.

Rose Krantz died Jan. 19 at 91. She is survived by her daughter, Muriel; and nephew, Joel (Ros) Linderman. Sholom Chapels

Michael Mandel died Jan. 18 at 59. He is survived by his wife, Galina; and son, Eugene. Sholom Chapels

Zipora Celina Manus died Jan. 20 at 77. She is survived by her husband, Stanley; daughters, Lee (Scott) Manus-McNutt and Donna Susskind; son, Michael; and four grandchildren. Mount Sinai

Selma Mitofsky died Jan. 19 at 88. She is survived by her husband Nathan; sons, Melvyn (Tracey) and Alan (Phyllis); daughters, Robyn (Brad) Halpern, and Suzan (Steven ) Lurie; 10 grandchildren; six great-grandchildren; and brorther, Emanuel Kolton. Mount Sinai

Ann Secof died Jan 15 at 87. She is survived by her stepson, Sam (Susanne); daughter, Candie (Marc) Shwartz-Rogers; three grandchildren; four great-grandchildren; and sisters, Leah Knopf, Shirley Rushnawitz and Rachel Ruchlemer. Chevra Kadisha

Omron Shaouli died Jan. 11 at 88. He is survived by his wife, Shirley; children, John and Lilian; and five grandchildren.

Constance Stone Shulman died Dec. 19 at 83. She is survived by her daughter, Stefanie (Tim) Masters; son, Larry (Janis Hirsch); five grandchildren; and sister, Donna Stone. Mount Sinai

Dorothy Rae Shulman died Jan. 18 at 85. She is survived by her daughters Lynn Trabert and Lori Tilkin; and son, Dan. Malinow and Silverman

Harry Weintraub died Jan. 19 at 89. He is survived by beloved wife, Rita; son, Bernard; and grandchildren. Hillside

Tracker Pixel for Entry


View our privacy policy and terms of service.