Jewish Journal

Madoff’s victims: Moving on, yet mesmerized by the spectacle

By Jacob Berkman, Jewish Telegraphic Agency

Posted on Jun. 30, 2009 at 4:58 pm

For Belle Faber, the sentencing of Bernard Madoff felt surreal.

Television coverage of Monday’s event was being projected on a screen in the conference room of the American Jewish Congress, one of the Jewish nonprofits hit hardest by Madoff’s thievery. Faber, the organization’s development director for nearly 25 years, had retreated into her office to watch CNN by herself.

The archival footage of Madoff flickering across the screen showed the person that had sat across from Faber numerous times in the offices of AJCongress, which Madoff once served as a board member. Faber even knew Madoff’s wife, Ruth, and recently came across an old note she wrote to the Madoffs wishing them a good trip to Florida.

Who could have known then what Madoff was doing?

Still, Faber says, she doesn’t wish vengeance on Madoff, even though he bilked his victims, including Faber’s organization, out of up to $65 billion. The AJCongress lost $21 million—90 percent of its endowment—in Madoff’s Ponzi scheme, forcing the organization to lay off 25 staff members.

On Monday, a U.S. District Court judge sentenced Madoff to 150 years in prison, the maximum penalty for his crimes.

“I have left a legacy of shame,” Madoff said in the Manhattan courtroom before his sentencing, according to media reports. “This is something I will live in for the rest of my life.”

Madoff’s shame was little solace for some of those he hurt.

“Mr. Madoff is not going to find any sympathy from us,” said Marc Stern, acting co-executive director of AJCongress. “There has been a 150-year sentence in the case of a 71-year-old man. It is not in practical terms very great, but in symbolic terms it is very significant.”

“It doesn’t give us our $20 million back,” Stern went on. “That is inherent in these sorts of processes. It is satisfaction mixed with the reality that it does not undo the harm that he did.”

For some charities decimated by Madoff, things will never be the same.

The Robert I. Lappin Foundation, whose entire $8 million in assets was wiped out by Madoff’s scheme, was transformed by the loss.

It used to fund programs such as Youth to Israel, which sends kids from Massachusetts on free trips to Israel, out of its own once-deep pockets; now the foundation must raise funds to survive. New programs, like one that would have sent teachers to Israel, have been put on hold, according to Deboah Coltin, the foundation’s executive director.

“If I was to sum it up, justice was served. What else is there to say?” Coltin said. “The Lappin Foundation has been able to pick up and move on. We haven’t been thinking about it.”

In Los Angeles, the Jewish Community Foundation (JCF) lost an $18-million investment that had grown to $25.5 million on paper. Those funds, once part of a common-investment pool that the JCF manages for most of the community’s blue-blood Jewish nonprofits, included $6.4 million of the Jewish Federation of Greater Los Angeles’ endowment of, at the time, about $70 million.

The Chais Family Foundation, which gave about $12.5 million a year to Jewish causes in the United States, Israel and the former Soviet Union and had assets of $178 million, said it lost everything when Madoff revealed his scam and immediately closed its doors.

Stanley Chais, the foundation’s 83-year-old chairman, was a longtime Beverly Hills money manager who completely invested his clients and his own family in Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities. Chais is now the subject of a $250 million class-action lawsuit, as well as lawsuits by the court-appointed trustee liquidating Madoff’s firm and the Securities and Exchange Commission. Each of the lawsuits claim Chais was complicit in Madoff’s great swindle.

In response to the SEC complaint last week, Chais, through his attorneys, denied any wrongdoing, as he has done for the past seven months.

“Like so many others, Mr. Chais was blindsided and victimized by Bernard Madoff’s unprecedented and pervasive fraud,” Chais attorney Eugene Licker said. “Mr. Chais and his family have lost virtually everything – an impossible result were he involved in the underlying fraud.”

Faber said she often wondered if a check made out to the AJCongress was among the stack of checks for tens of millions of dollars that investigators found in Madoff’s desk after he was arrested—because maybe, just maybe, Madoff would have wanted to do right by the charities he had devastated.

Watching coverage of the trial, Faber said she felt the charity world she had known was gone.

“We will never see the kind of beneficence we have always seen in the future because of what happened,” Faber said. “He has changed the whole fabric of the Jewish community, especially when it comes to organizations like ours.”

Jewish Journal senior writer Brad A. Greenberg contributed to this report.

Tracker Pixel for Entry


View our privacy policy and terms of service.