It is getting somewhat boring to read yet another letter in The Jewish Journal from such a disingenuous character as Hussam Ayloush (Letters, Dec. 1). Typical of Ayloush and other CAIR officials, he engages only in ad hominem smears and refuses to deal with the substantive claims. One only needs to do a little research to uncover his obvious fabrications.
First, it is ironic that he says that I "resort to deception" by stating that CAIR has engaged in anti-Semitism in the past. It is notable here that Ayloush conveniently fails to address the fact that neo-Nazi William Baker has been invited to speak at several CAIR events -- whose presence at those events Ayloush himself has defended.
Also, Ayloush categorically lies when he states that "CAIR has no connection, direct or indirect, to the event he referred to in New York" in which radical Islamist cleric Wagdy Ghoneim made anti-Semitic statements and led the crowd in an anti-Semitic song. In fact, CAIR's name is listed on the event announcement, along with several other groups including the Holy Land Foundation, as a co-sponsor. The event itself was sponsored by the Islamic Association for Palestine, which was hit with a $156 million civil judgment -- along with the Holy Land Foundation and several other entities -- by a federal court in Illinois in a case in which the family of a murdered victim of Hamas terrorism successfully sued U.S.-based Hamas front organizations.
Maybe the problem here is one of language and definition. Perhaps, to Ayloush, neo-Nazis and songs lyrics such as, "No to the Jews, descendants of the Apes" are not anti-Semitic.
Investigative Project on Terrorism
Ed. Note: The Journal has invited Steven Emerson and Hussam Ayloush to continue their exchange in an e-mail forum at jewishjournal.com. This letter will be posted there awaiting Mr. Ayloush's response.
Hussan Ayloush has managed to manipulate and use The Jewish Journal as his mouthpiece to discredit Steve Emerson. I wonder if any of the Islamic papers would allow such use of their papers for us to discredit Ayloush.
Steven Emerson has been warning the government about radical Islam long before anyone knew about CAIR and Ayloush. Had our government listened to the warnings that Emerson made them aware of instead of trying to appear politically correct, or just naive, more than 3,000 people would be alive today. We would have been prepared for the promotion of Sharia law, and accommodations made for Islam that are not made for either Judaism or Christianity in the United States.
Your paper has allowed an apologist for terror in the United States as well as in Israel to use your pages to promote his agenda, propaganda and lies. This is just shameful.
Allyson Rowen Taylor
Prager and the Quran
I don't know which is worse; Dennis Prager's virulent intolerance and Islamaphobia or his pathetic ignorance of what our "American values" really are ("Prager Opposition to Quran Congress Rite Draws Fire," Dec. 8). Surely even he would agree that the U.S. Constitution reflects cherished "American values" to which we can all adhere.
Article VI, on the very topic of the oath of office, says, and I quote in full to give the context: "The Senators and Representatives before mentioned, and the members of the several state legislatures, and all executive and judicial officers, both of the United States and of the several states, shall be bound by oath or affirmation, to support this Constitution; but no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States."
How dare Prager set himself above the Constitution, and claim that anyone who does not take an oath on the Bible can't serve in Congress? It's Prager that shouldn't serve on the United States Holocaust Memorial Council if he does not share the American value of religious free exercise protected by the First Amendment.
Stephen F. Rohde
The writer is a constitutional lawyer
I wish the journal would do their homework on Keith Ellison. If you simply Google "Ellison Jews" you would find that he defended a colleague's right to say "the most racist white people are Jews"; that he sat silently while Khalid Muhammand spewed a racist rant; that he defended in writing Farakhan's not being anti-Semitic; that he his funded by CAIR, a known front group for Hamas. It's most disturbing that Jewish organizations would defend this guy without knowing the truth.
Dear Jon Drucker, your suggestion that we sneak into seeing Mel Gibson's movie "Apocalypto" although we paid to see a different movie is bad advice ("Skip Into Mel Gibson's 'Apocalypto' Now," Dec 8). It reminded me of last year when I read that Abraham Foxman, the head of the Anti-Defamation League, had snuck into a free preview of "The Passion" without being invited.
As a Jew, I was totally embarrassed by Foxman's actions. If you want to see the movie, act like a responsible adult and pay the price. You will be providing a better example for everyone, Jews and non-Jews. Leave "skipping" for the kids.
I feel reassured to learn that measures are taken to keep sexual predators, evil opportunists and other dark characters away from shul ("Getting Kicked Out of Shul," Dec. 8). The safe environment this creates makes for a more spiritual experience without, as a single woman, having to fear for my safety.
I want to take this opportunity to thank all the rabbis for taking on the responsibility of doing what it takes to create the safe and loving environment we enjoy at shul, in addition to their already demanding work.
Beth Jacob Congregation
Your front-page article of Dec 8 shows that we Jews continue to be our own worst enemy -- and sadly, The Jewish Journal is leading the way in making us look nasty or foolish to our own community and certainly to the general L.A. community ("Getting Kicked Out of Shul).
We welcome your feedback.
Your information will not be shared or sold without your consent. Get all the details.
Terms of Service
JewishJournal.com has rules for its commenting community.Get all the details.
JewishJournal.com reserves the right to use your comment in our weekly print publication.