David Myers' message on the disengagement from Gaza is moving and powerful and wonderfully significant ("Show Gaza Sympathies to the Other," Aug. 26). It is a call to conscience and a much-need reminder that what lies at the heart of the Jewish ethos is the conviction that the Jewish conscience has no boundaries. The Gaza settlers, the impoverished Israelis, the Arab citizens of Israel, the Palestinians -- there must be a compassionate place for all of them on the walls of a Jewish heart.
Rabbi Leonard Beerman
In his article, David Myers shows his universalism first. He has little sympathy for the settlers who did not take any money. Apparently, they had higher motives in not wanting to leave their homes.
Recently we watched the scenes of evacuees and soldiers. One could not help but be proud of the Israel Defense Forces as they carried out their duty with so much sympathy for the anguish of the settler. Disengagement was a wrenching experience for all of Israel. One needs time to mourn and contemplate its effect on the history of the nation.
Myers does not even allow a mourning period. He immediately chastises us for not showing empathy toward the Palestinians. He neglected to mention that Jews were evicted from all the Arab countries, leaving behind far greater wealth.
You don't hear about these Jewish refugees. Israel did not keep them in refugee camps for more than 50 years. They were integrated into the society.
We teach children to first love themselves because only then can they love a friend or the "other." This applies to adults, as well. In the fullness of time, the other will come to understand that the gestures of friendship which Israel has demonstrated over the years deserve to be reciprocated.
Like a Virgin
In response to Amy Klein's column, "Like a Virgin" (Aug. 19), I would like to offer a response to the last few lines of the article: "But a 40-year-old virgin? Save it for the movies, because it's so sad you'd have to laugh."
While I would agree that it would appear to be atypical or uncommon to have existed on this planet for 40 years (let alone 40 days and 40 nights, as far as many people are concerned) without ever having had sexual relations with another person, I would hardly call it "sad." Better a 40-year-old virgin (who perhaps is just selective and sensitive enough to want to wait for the right person and have a caring, more meaningful relationship with a true connection) than a 20-something who just wants to "romp around" because he/she "can" or because "everyone else is doing it. I'm sure my nearly 50-year-old male virgin friend would agree.
Name Withheld Upon Request
Claim Won't Hold
A Nation/World brief in your Aug. 19 issue reported that entertainer Harry Belafonte recently claimed Jews were "high up in the Third Reich" ("Oy, Mr. Tallyman," Aug. 19). After protests by the David S. Wyman Institute for Holocaust Studies, Belafonte backtracked and admitted that "Jews weren't 'high up'" in the Hitler regime, but he then claimed: "Jews did have a role, some did, in the demise and brutal treatment of the Jewish people [during the Holocaust]." (Jerusalem Post, Aug. 11, 2005) Your article noted that Belafonte claimed my book, "Hitler's Jewish Soldiers," supports his charge.
"Hitler's Jewish Soldiers" shows that a number of people of partial Jewish ancestry served in the German military, but they did not even consider themselves Jews. Moreover, the vast majority of them were drafted -- they were forced to serve Hitler just as other Jews were forced to become slave laborers in Auschwitz and elsewhere. In fact, many of them were later dismissed from the German military and sent to forced labor camps where they themselves were persecuted and some were murdered. Belafonte should take the trouble to read the books he cites, before claiming they support him. My book does not support him.
Bryan Mark Rigg
author of "Hitler's Jewish Soldiers"
Death by Oprah
I picked up The Jewish Journal, opened the back page and was drawn in by the title of an article by Annie Korzen: "Death by Oprah" (Aug. 19). I read the first paragraph, and became excited at the prospect of reading, finally, an intelligent discourse from an expert who writes about "the ugly stereotypes Jewish men have created about their wives and mothers."
But it was all downhill after that. Rather than being a spokesperson for Jewish women, Korzen went on to prove these stereotypes by her own words and deeds, descriptions of her own behavior proving the reputed ugliness is all too true. Her piggish eating habits and self-denigrating jokes proved the opposite of what she supposedly set out to do, which is to destroy stereotypes, the reason she was invited on "Oprah." Her so-called humor served only to further the ugly clichés about Jewish women.
What a pity, taking up two columns of a Jewish newspaper to serve the callous cause of stereotyping Jewish women, who deserve better that that. With friends like Korzen, we Jewish women don't need enemies.
In "Classnotes: Genesis Generation" (Aug. 26), The first name of Jenna Barocas was incorrectly written as Jennifer.
The Journal's question, "After Gaza, Can Religious Jews Still Believe in Israel?" is entirely wrong (Cover Story, Aug. 12). In fact, it is quite the opposite. Ultimately, the vast majority of religious Jews will emerge with their faith in Israel intact -- even if challenged by Israel's secular administration and its surreal, morally evil expulsion plan, whereby 10,000 of Israel's best citizens suffered unimaginable loss and pain.
As for the nonreligious Jews (not the non-observant, many of whom may well be Jews of faith), what will be the degree and quality of their belief in Israel now that we have experienced the expulsion from Gaza?
More than 1,000 proud and hugely productive Gush Katif families, a number of them nonreligious, are today homeless -- adrift throughout Israel -- due to unfulfilled government promises. Illustrative is the experience of certain expelled secularists who arrived at their promised quarters only to be turned away. The facility owners now lacked confidence in the government's promise of payment. Once again, these Jews became outcasts.
Belief in God's word and their spirituality enable the religious to say, "Next year in Jerusalem." But will the nonreligious outcasts be able to recover belief in Israel? That is a more appropriate question.
Julian M. White
Notwithstanding the arguments of Hirsh Goodman ("Israel's Future -- Not Terrorism -- Won in Gaza," Aug. 26) on the strategic benefits and objectives for Israel of the Gaza withdrawal, the perception held almost unanimously by Palestinians is that tactics of terror have driven Israel out of Gaza. That is the only lesson that the Palestinians will draw from the Gaza withdrawal, and now they will try to apply it in the rest of Israel, with disastrous results for themselves and for many Israelis.
One might request that Goodman at least not repeat the Arab propaganda claim that Gaza is "the most populated piece of real estate in the world." Had he devoted even a few minutes to fact-checking, Goodman would have found that, with more than 1.3 million people in 138 square miles, Gaza has a density of 9,971 persons per square mile. That is about 57 percent of the density of Hong Kong (17,377) and less than 15 percent of the density of Manhattan (66,844).
Ralph B. Kostant
Most paleontologists admit that fossils have not proven the validity of classical evolution ("Junk" Science, Aug. 12). Microfossils of bacteria occur immediately after the appearance of water on Earth. Almost 530 million years ago, with no hint in earlier fossils, the Cambrian explosion of life appeared with all the body plans represented in animal phyla extant today, simultaneously, in a single burst in the fossil record. Classes developed within each phyla, but they retained the basic body plan of their particular phylum. Animals make their sudden appearance highly specialized and fully developed, last their time and disappear essentially the same. One of the great mysteries of animal evolution is why no new phyla have appeared since the Cambrian age. These rapid staccato changes cannot be explained by purely random mutations at the molecular genetic level. Microevolution within a species has been well documented but there is no data to support macroevolution. The persistence of theories for a randomly driven evolution of life in the face of the data from molecular biology and the fossil record, both replete with evidence against it, is purely a matter of cognitive dissidence.
Dr. Sabi Israel
David Myers, in his zeal to support our enemies and oppose our own interests, lied ("Show Gaza Sympathies to the Other," Aug. 26). Houses were demolished in Gaza, Samaria, Judea and Jerusalem not "without reason." As is well known, they were houses of terrorists, and a Turkish law, kept on the books by the British occupiers and still retained by us in our independence, decrees their razing; or houses threatening innocent civilians passing on the roads. Does the professor think that they were picked at random, destroyed on whim?
He turned truth on its head: In 1948 it was Jews in Muslim countries who were dispossessed and exiled (or hanged, as in Baghdad), not Palestinian Muslims: Some of those fled out of fear of reprisal for attacking Jews, or in obedience to the Arab high command to "clear the battlefield" for genocide of the Jews. Even so, their property was kept in trust for them until a peace settlement.
Nursing their enmity toward us for generations, they should not be "permitted back". Every trace of their occupation of the land of Israel (as they originally called it) might well be erased. The millions of Arabs living well as Israeli citizens are there by Israeli sufferance, not by any right. They keep the peace. The refugees didn't and don't.
We welcome your feedback.
Your information will not be shared or sold without your consent. Get all the details.
Terms of Service
JewishJournal.com has rules for its commenting community.Get all the details.
JewishJournal.com reserves the right to use your comment in our weekly print publication.