Jewish Journal

When Roger Waters crossed the line

by Noga Gur-Arieh

July 26, 2013 | 10:30 am

From criticism to anti-Semitism/ Taken by @itsme211.

Roger Waters is a passionate anti-Israeli advocate. The former Pink Floyd frontman constantly criticize the Israeli government, and is one of the main voices of the BDS movement, calling musicians to boycott Israel. Last Saturday, however, Waters crossed the thin line between criticism and anti-Semitism, insulting many of his fans and marking himself as a hater.

The story of Waters and Israeli began in 2006, when Waters performed in the Israeli village of Ne've' Shalom in front of some 60,000 people. A day earlier, he visited the West Bank barrier (aka separation fence and has since become very involved in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Waters has become an anti-Israeli advocate, passionately calling Israel to cease the Palestinian occupation and make love, not war.

I don't agree with many of the things he says, and most certainly don't believe that calling for BDS is the right path to peace, but in spite of it all, I know his opinion came from being here, seeing and experiencing and concluding, and not while sitting at home and receiving second handed information from the press. Therefore, while I don't agree with his conclusions from his visit here, I always respected his opinion. It bothered me, it punched me in the gut every single time he opened his mouth, but it was respected. That is, until his concert last Saturday at Werchter, Belguim.

At some point in the concert, a big, black swine-shaped balloon appeared, with several symbols on it, including the symbols of well-known fascist regimes, logos of both corporations, and a Star of David, the famous Jewish symbol. At that point, Waters crossed the line, from a passionate artist with a criticism, to a hateful person, sending to the world painful anti-Semitic messages that were supposed to be buried with Hitler.

Some members of the audience didn't even notice the Jews/pigs/greed triangle, but some, including Jewish and Israeli fans, were deeply insulted by the big snoring racist announcement floating over the stage. It is possible that some of them agreed with Waters' legitimate criticism of the Israeli government. It is a complicated reality we live in, and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is very controversial, as some Israelis, who love Israel, agree with Waters' opinion. However, anti-Semitism is not controversial. In fact, it is very simple. It is not a criticism, but a message of hate, coming from hateful people.

Waters sees himself as a messenger whose purpose is to make the world a better place. He is trying to call for peace, for social justice and for equality. But instead, either subconsciously or on purpose, he now sends a message of pure hate that takes us back to a darker time decades ago. I can't imagine what went inside the minds of his Jewish fans at that concert. I only know that when I saw the picture of that swine, a shiver passed through my bones, and that feeling became even worse when I saw people commenting on the concert, without even noticing the hateful message. Did they ignore it? Did they agree? Or worse, did it enter their subconscious and settled there, nesting, waiting to burst in an act of violence?

Roger Waters, in case you are reading this- stop what you're doing, look back, and try to remember your original cause. Think about ways of improving the world, not ruin it. 

Tracker Pixel for Entry


View our privacy policy and terms of service.



My name is Noga Gur-Arieh, and I’m an Israeli Journalist, currently studying for my B.A degree in Media and Political Science, at Tel Aviv University.

I am very socially...

Read more.