Cover Story

July 20, 2010

The Israeli Conversion Bill:  What it means and why everyone’s so mad

by Jonah Lowenfeld, Staff Writer

Tweet

Share

Last week, Knesset member David Rotem unveiled a new draft of a bill that he claimed would expand, liberalize and rationalize Israel’s system of conversion. The bill would also hand over to Israel’s Orthodox Chief Rabbinate unprecedented new “responsibility over the subject of conversion.” On July 12, it passed through the Knesset’s Constitution, Law and Justice Committee and reignited the debate over the rabbinate’s role in Israeli society. It also revived the ultra-sensitive “who is a Jew?” question and set off a firestorm of criticism in a number of Israeli circles and letter-writing protest campaigns among Jewish communities across the world.

There is much confusion about what the Chief Rabbinate of Israel (Amendment — Jurisdiction Regarding Conversions) Bill, 5770-2010 does and does not say. Some observers wonder what — if any — practical impact it would have if passed.

As of The Journal’s press time on July 20, the bill had not yet had its first reading before the Knesset plenum. On July 18, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu reiterated his opposition to the bill in a cabinet meeting, saying that it could “tear apart the Jewish people.” The bill could still reach the Knesset floor on July 21, the last day before the Knesset breaks for a recess that will last through the end of the High Holy Days, but in light of Netanyahu’s strong statement, it is highly unlikely that the Rotem bill will have come to a vote by the time this story is published, as any bill has to go through three readings in the Knesset before becoming law. But even if a clear outcome is somehow reached, the historic fight over the Rotem bill involves so many competing interests in Israel and has inspired such fierce protest from so many Jews in the Diaspora that it demands a closer look.

Few people can say exactly what the Rotem bill will do. “If you were to read a translation, it would be baffling,” said Rabbi Uri Regev, CEO and president of the Israeli educational and advocacy organization Hiddush, which is dedicated to “Freedom of Religion and Equality.” According to Regev, Rotem’s three-page bill claims to accomplish two things: “One, to provide greater availability of conversion venues for the new immigrants — namely authorizing more rabbis, and among them hopefully some lenient rabbis to do conversions.” The bill’s other stated aim, Regev said, is to address “the phenomenon of rabbinic courts that hold that Orthodox conversions are null and void.”

The “new immigrants” that Regev, Rotem and everyone else has been talking about are those who came to Israel from the former Soviet Union. Many of them support the right-wing, secular and nationalist Yisrael Beiteinu Party. Rotem is one of the party’s 15 ministers, and the party is in Netanyahu’s ruling coalition.

Approximately 1 million citizens from the former Soviet Union live in Israel today, and like all olim (Jews who move to Israel), they became Israeli citizens under the Law of Return. But, although under that law a person can qualify for citizenship simply by having a Jewish father or grandparent, she (or he) will not be considered a Jew by the rabbinate’s Orthodox standards without being able to trace a clear lineage of matrilineal Jewish roots, or else undergoing an Orthodox conversion. Approximately 350,000 of the Israelis from the former Soviet Union — 15 percent of Israel’s citizens — are not Jews according to the Orthodox rabbinate. And because the rabbinate has, since the Jewish state’s founding, been in charge of all major lifecycle events in Israel — including birth, marriage, divorce and burial — that status has serious implications. “They are Israeli citizens,” Regev said, but “they cannot marry in Israel.”

So it is understandable why Rotem might wish to resolve this situation. Even the bill’s most outspoken critics agree that something must be done.

“The bill started from a good place,” said Gilad Kariv, the head of the Reform movement in Israel. Rotem was not the first legislator, Kariv said, to try to “deal with the Orthodox conversion crisis,” nor was this most recent draft Rotem’s first attempt. But this bill diverged from Rotem’s earlier drafts, Kariv said, by adding a “disturbing element”: “To buy the Charedi [ultra-orthodox] parties,” Kariv said, Rotem “agreed to put exclusive authority over conversion in Israel into the hands of the Chief Rabbinate.”

“It will be first time that the issue of conversion will be handed over to the Chief Rabbinate,” Kariv said.

On a single page

1 | 2 | 3     Next Page

A version of this article appeared in print.

---

Post your comment below!

Click here to return to the homepage.

COMMENTS

We welcome your feedback. Comments may not exceed 700 characters.

Privacy Policy

Your information will not be shared or sold without your consent. Get all the details.

Terms of Service

JewishJournal.com has rules for its commenting community.Get all the details.

How many parents say “I dont care what you do outside the home, but, when you’re in THIS house you will…(fill in the blank) -why ? because our homes are sanctified. The conversion rules at “home” (Israel) may be and MUST be “Sanctified”. What the Conservative and reform movements want, is for anyone to proclaim themselves “Jewish” with the rest of us having no choice but to accept them. Sorry, Olim, but if you want to marry MY daughter, you need to be more “Jewish” than merely “Jewish by Name”.

Comment by Jeffrey B. on 7/20/10 at 4:36 pm

Jeffrey B.- As a convert, for my conversion, I learned about all the major Jewish movements, and specifically had to answer questions about the beliefs of each on my written exam. Do you know much about any of the other movements?  I also read, write and speak Hebrew (also taught in conversion class) well for someone 3 years into being a practicing Jew.  Be more “Jewish”? My experience is that most Jews by Choice at my Shul tend to be more observant than those born Jewish.  It doesn’t however make us more “Jewish”.  Just more observant.  That does not make anyone better than anyone else.  G-d made people capable of making and being responsible for their own observance as they see fit.

Comment by Randal S. on 7/25/10 at 1:46 am

Yes it may be true that politics,and bureaucracy have too much influence. This matter requires decency and principled,consistent solutions. That being said, political correctness is equally to blame. It is unreasonable to ask; How are Rabbis from different denominations with exceedingly different practices and beliefs capable of converting people to to the same faith? This has nothing to do with “Who is a Jew” and everything to do with an honest respectful conversation the Jewish people need to have like sisters and brothers
sitting around a kitchen table.

Comment by Rafael Guber on 7/26/10 at 8:25 am

Randal S. -
Your post doesn’t state under which denomination you converted, so your post may or may not agree with mine.
As to the rest, what you dont understand, is that a Jew is a Jew (observance level notwithstanding) - BUT, that only comes into play once you ARE a Jew - not before.
G-d DID make “Jews”, but PEOPLE made “converted Jews”.

Comment by Jeffrey B. on 7/26/10 at 11:09 am

Post a Comment

Name:
Email:

Type the word you see below:

Comment:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?