Cover Story

January 25, 2012

Can we afford kosher lettuce?

By Jonah Lowenfeld

Tweet

Share

On a Monday morning in November, two men sat on the edge of a field in Carpinteria, 85 miles north of Los Angeles. The older one, middle-aged, wiry and bareheaded, had the face of someone who has served in the military, worked in agriculture or, in his case, both. Alongside him was a younger man who wore a black kippah and looked, from his complexion, like he spends his days indoors.

Between them, a young head of romaine lettuce sat on a table. It was cracked open, the small leaves splayed outward to reveal a few flecks of soil.

“Did you see anything moving?” the older man asked.

“No,” the younger one replied. “No, this looks very good.”

Yossi Asyag, 45, is an Israeli-born agricultural entrepreneur and the founder of a small farming operation that grows kosher-certified fresh lettuce and herbs. Yosef Caplan, 27, is assistant director of the kashrut services division at the Rabbinical Council of California (RCC). Every Monday, Caplan drives from Los Angeles to Carpinteria and then to another site nearby for his job as Asyag’s farm’s mashgiach, or kosher supervisor.

That nothing was moving in the lettuce on the table on this day left both Asyag and Caplan hopeful that no bugs inhabited the other 5,000 heads of lettuce growing in the greenhouse a few dozen yards away.

Harvest time would come two weeks later. Through a combination of careful monitoring and judicious application of pesticides, Asyag said, the lettuce in the greenhouse stayed bug-free. That week’s haul of romaine lettuce from the farm was certified as kosher.

Worse than a cheeseburger

The presence of even one whole bug, dead or alive, can render an entire vegetable treif — unkosher. On this matter, Orthodox rabbis are unequivocal.

“From a Torah perspective, eating a Big Mac or eating a salad with insects in it, the salad is worse,” Rabbi Eliezer Eidlitz, who runs the nonprofit Kosher Information Bureau, told me when I met him at his home office in Valley Village.

With stakes like that, it’s no wonder some kosher-observant Jews are willing to pay top dollar for kosher-certified produce. At one store in Los Angeles earlier this month, an RCC-certified head of romaine was selling for seven times the per-ounce price of one without the kosher designation. For East Coast consumers, who buy the majority of Asyag’s produce, most of the lettuce is first pre-cut and bagged as processed salads, and then sold at an even higher markup.

Greenhouse-grown, bug-free kosher lettuce is an Israeli innovation. First pioneered in 1990 in the then-occupied Gaza Strip, the growing technique is still often referred to as the “Gush Katif” method, named for the now-dismantled Jewish settlement where it originated.

Over the past five years, California has become home to the largest North American bug-free-growing operation, and it’s about to get bigger. Asyag, who has been selling RCC-certified lettuce under the brand California Kosher Farms since around 2008, is about to embark on a major expansion, aiming to double his farm’s output over the next 12 months to more than 1 million heads of lettuce a year. He’s looking to buy more land in Oxnard and has already started using Israeli-designed hydroponics to grow more lettuce in less space.

But while the equation “lettuce minus bugs plus rabbinic approval equals good returns,” might seem simple, the reality is anything but. This nascent industry is fraught with disputes, not just over what Jewish law requires, but over what price consumers and businesses should have to pay in order to keep their salads kosher.

Through dozens of interviews with growers, rabbis, local kosher caterers and staff from one local kosher supervision agency, a complicated picture emerges of a niche business that illustrates the complexities and the unusual financial challenges of the modern kosher marketplace. One thing is certain: It is the RCC supervisors who hold most of the cards.

The RCC does not have an ownership interest in the operations of the farm that grows the vegetables it certifies; nevertheless, the farm would not exist without RCC certification and support. In aiming for the absolute highest standard of kosher, the RCC — widely considered the most stringent and broadly accepted kosher certifying body in the region — has chosen to certify just one grower, granting him a monopoly and even privileging his interests over those of the caterers the RCC also certifies.

“These ladies were scrubbing the lettuce with soap.”

Unlike, say, the prohibition on eating pork or shellfish, few non-Orthodox Jews today know about the “no bugs” kosher requirement. A section about insects from the fourth edition of Eidlitz’s book “Is it Kosher? An Encyclopedia of Kosher Food, Facts, and Fallacies” suggests that even as recently as 1999, the author’s largely Orthodox readership wasn’t paying as much attention to keeping bugs out of their food as he thought they should.

“Although eating insects is strictly forbidden by the Torah, we find this concern often overlooked,” Eidlitz writes. In the 1950s and ’60s, Eidlitz said in an interview, when the application of dangerous pesticides, including DDT, ensured that very few bugs could be found on American produce, leading rabbinic authorities gave permission to kosher-observant American Orthodox Jews to “overlook” these laws.

Not anymore. In the last 20 years, Orthodox rabbis in general, and those involved in kosher certification in particular, have been working hard to introduce — reintroduce, they say — practices of checking fresh vegetables for bugs in observance of the laws of kashrut.

Blanket bans have been issued on the most bug-friendly and hardest-to-check produce: raspberries, blackberries, whole artichokes and more are entirely forbidden because they’re too complex and fragile in form (the berries) or too tightly closed (artichokes) to inspect. And the Web site of every major kosher certifying agency includes guidebooks, instructional pamphlets, even videos outlining a labor-intensive regimen designed to rid other vegetables of insects.

Such extreme cleaning and checking can seem unusual to an outsider.

“I was in Crown Heights last week doing a demonstration where these ladies were scrubbing the lettuce with soap,” I was told by Geila Hocherman, a Cordon Bleu-trained chef based in New York who co-wrote the cookbook “Kosher Revolution,” published last year.

But the insects they’re looking for are tiny — and seemingly everywhere. Arugula leaves and asparagus tips are potential hiding spots for thrips — 1-millimeter-long insects that can be seen with the naked eye but are easier to spot with a magnifying glass. Pinhead-sized aphids can lurk in and around the florets of broccoli and in bunches of fresh parsley. As for spider mites, which, despite their name, are not related to spiders, the minuscule creatures (less than 1 millimeter in diameter) can seem impossible to eliminate.

“When a spider mite gets into the lettuce, even if you wash it, it doesn’t let go,” Asyag said. “It’s like the leg gets in.”

This new vigilance has changed some observant people’s diets, too: Hocherman, who describes her own Jewish observance as “very Modern Orthodox,” included in “Kosher Revolution” a number of recipes that run afoul of the vegetable-related rules instituted by the Orthodox rabbinical establishment.

The main ingredient in Glazed Brussels Sprouts With Chestnuts, for example, “should not be used,” according to the RCC, as the sprouts’ tight leaves could hide bugs. Broccoli florets, an important part of Hocherman’s recipe for Cold Sesame Noodles With Broccoli and Tofu, must be parboiled before they can be checked, according to the Orthodox Union (OU), and if three or more bugs are found, the whole head must be thrown away.

And consider the situation facing green asparagus. “What they’re asking us to do is to cut off the tips and shave the sides,” said Errol Fine, explaining why the vegetable is no longer on the menu at Pat’s, the upscale restaurant in the heart of Pico-Robertson he owns with his wife. Pat’s restaurant and catering business both are certified by Kehilla Kosher, a Los Angeles kosher certification agency run by Rabbi Avrohom Teichman, and Fine said he can’t remember when Pat’s last served asparagus.

“We should’ve had a farewell party,” he said, ruefully.

And it’s not just homemakers in predominantly Chasidic or “black-hat” neighborhoods who are washing their lettuce with soap, shaving and circumcising their asparagus spears and keeping their fruit platters free of raspberries and blackberries.

“I think by now the Orthodox Jewish community has been well educated that there is, or can be, an infestation problem, and that they need to check,” said Rabbi Elazar Muskin of Young Israel of Century City, a large Modern Orthodox synagogue, also in Pico-Robertson. Muskin was president of the RCC for five years in the 1990s, and he said that in those days people worried they might not be thorough enough in checking. Today, however, Muskin said his congregants are more comfortable with the task.

On a single page

1 | 2 | 3 | 4    Next Page

A version of this article appeared in print.

---

Post your comment below!

Click here to return to the homepage.

COMMENTS

We welcome your feedback. Comments may not exceed 700 characters.

Privacy Policy

Your information will not be shared or sold without your consent. Get all the details.

Terms of Service

JewishJournal.com has rules for its commenting community.Get all the details.

I cant comment now im off to get my 1st big Mac

Comment by jake Marx on 1/25/12 at 9:38 pm

Interesting concept. If one in 5,000 heads is bad, all the heads are bad and condemned to death or at least, to be non kosher.

Maybe we should do that with people. Say a small city of 5,000 christians has one police officer that is a nazi, complete with swastika tattoo on his chest. Since that officer works for the city and represents the city and the city serves and represents the people (in a republic or representative democracy), then we can use the same kosher rule. All the christians in that city are nazis.

Comment by joybook on 1/27/12 at 12:50 pm

continued

Of course we have to remember that this is not out of the realm of reality. All Nazis were and are christians. So, something like this could be true. It is definitely something to think about in a country where disenfranchised people are beaten and murdered by the police every week.

Comment by joybook on 1/27/12 at 12:51 pm

Great. More pesticides. Exactly what we need.

Comment by Rina on 1/27/12 at 2:33 pm

This is a new idea in the last decade, after thousands of years of simply washing and checking lettuce & other vegetables for bugs, Now we suddenly can only buy certified lettuce.  Hogwash.

Comment by Openeyes on 1/27/12 at 4:41 pm

While going to these extremes for the sake of kashrut is not what I would do, there a foodies all over this city who pay outrageous amounts of money for coffee drinks, molecular gastronomic meals and exotic sushi.  So, if someone wants to buy bug free lettuce, or refuses to eat Brussels sprouts, who’s to criticize what’s, at worst, just another culinary fetish?

Comment by Jeffrey on 1/27/12 at 7:32 pm

Wouldn’t it be more “Jewish” to take the additional amount that you would be willing to pay for “kosher” lettuce and and donate that amount to a food bank? Hhhmm….rinsing a bug off a lettuce leaf once a year vs. a family having food to eat. Tough choice.

Comment by Wendy on 1/28/12 at 1:06 am

Please don’t malign all insects ! Examples of kosher insects include the locust, the cricket, and the grasshopper (read Vayikra 11 carefully). Moreover, fried crickets don’t taste all that bad (common in Thailand). So you don’t have to wash away all the insects

Comment by Gershom on 1/28/12 at 3:37 am

1 of x: Let me understand this:  HaShem would rather His allegedly “chosen” people be poisoned with pesticides rather than have natural products merely touched by His creations.  Why not start using a microscope?  After all, there is no size limitation in the Torah or Talmud, and we know how to track even smaller insects.  Do you think that insects are limited to one millimeter?  Unlike many other religions and philosophies, HaShem offers us the chance to think, to question, to debate. (...)

Comment by Jared on 1/28/12 at 12:15 pm

2 of x:  I’ll bet my immortal soul that HaShem is more concerned with how we treat each other and the world He gave us for 364 days a year than He is impressed with requests for forgiveness on one day each year, and our willingness to invoke ever more hypertechnicalities in His name. (...)

Comment by Jared on 1/28/12 at 12:16 pm

3 of 3: Today one millimeter, tomorrow electron microscopes?  How dare we stop at a level of convenience?  Of course, while we don’t eat pigs, we don’t go around killing them, either ... same for lobsters. But insects, well, they’re ... insects ... so let’s kill them AND poison His people at the same time. You know, based upon a few lines from Genesis, you could actually prove that this level of behavior is a sin against HaShem. Never mind ... it’s just not worth it.

Comment by Jared on 1/28/12 at 12:17 pm

Let’s see…  with all that is going on in the world, the LAJJ editor-in-chief thinks stories about a Jewish actor (a couple of weeks ago) and kosher lettuce are important enough to be major cover stories.

What an embarrassment!

Comment by paul jeser on 1/28/12 at 3:02 pm

AS president of Jewish Vegetarians of North America, I think we should also consider if we can afford to continue to eat meat, since the production of meat and other animal products contributes very significantly to climate change, worldwide hunger, water and energy shortages, and many other environmental threats to all of humanity

Comment by Richard Schwartz on 1/29/12 at 2:24 am

One has to ask if something was fine 50 years ago, what’s changed?
1) checking for bugs is a terrific make-work project for women. Keeps women confused and frightened about kashrut, further ensuring more rabbinic control over their lives.
2) at 5.50 for a (checked) broccoli, the costs add up fast to feed a family. So another vitamin-packed vegetable, like kale, spinach, brussel sprouts and cauliflower, gets sidelined.
Not in my house.

Comment by Dorothy Lipovenko on 1/30/12 at 6:59 am

Post a Comment

Name:
Email:

Type the word you see below:

Comment:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?