Jewish Journal

A debate on Israel’s loyalty oath

by JewishJournal.com

Posted on Oct. 20, 2010 at 11:09 am

Last weekend, thousands of Israeli Jews and Arabs demonstrated in Tel Aviv against a proposed loyalty oath that would require a pledge of allegiance by non-Jews to the “Jewish and democratic state of Israel.” On Oct. 18, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said the new amendment to the Citizenship Act, approved the previous week by Israel’s Cabinet by a vote of 22-8, should also include Jews seeking Israeli citizenship under the Law of Return.

Human rights groups and political organizations, in Israel and abroad, have slammed the amendment as racist.

The protesters marching Oct. 16 carried signs reading “Jews and Arabs refuse to be enemies” and “In Nuremberg it also began with legislation!”

Many of the demonstrators were from the Arab Israeli Hadash Party and the left-wing Meretz Party, who co-sponsored the march from Gan Meir Park to the Kirya Defense Ministry headquarters under the banner “Together Against Racism — Arab and Jewish March for Democracy.”

The amendment advances to the Knesset’s legislative committee before moving on to the full Knesset.

The loyalty oath amendment fulfills part of the government’s coalition agreement with Avidgor Lieberman’s Yisrael Beiteinu Party.

On Oct. 15, the main body of American Reform rabbis opposed the loyalty oath in a statement saying that it “would turn Israel into the very kind of country which historically Jews themselves have rightly cursed for their unequal treatment of non-Christians and non-Muslims. More than symbolic loyalty statements, Israel needs its non-Jewish citizens as partners in peace, equally invested in the future of the state.”

The Reform body represents about 2,000 U.S. rabbis.

What follows are two opinions on the issue.

Why the loyalty oath is a good deal

By David Suissa

Maybe it’s because I was a Jew in an Arab country that I have a slightly different take on the loyalty oath controversy. Imagine, for a minute, that your name is Ahmed and you are a gay Palestinian living in Ramallah. You live in fear of being outed, ostracized, even jailed and tortured. A few miles away is a Jewish and democratic nation called Israel. Your partner, who is Arab and lives there, has been telling you for years that he suffers no discrimination from being gay. In fact, a few months ago, he danced in the Gay Pride Parade in Jerusalem with full protection from the Israeli authorities.  MORE.

Israel’s future depends on its ability to prevent, solve tensions between being ‘Jewish,’ ‘democratic’

by Michael Herzog

There are issues in the life of a nation and a country that must not be turned into pawns in an internal political game and must not be cashed into tactical coins. One of them, if not the foremost among them, is the foundational idea of the State of Israel, the unique nation-state of the Jewish people, which practices the universal values of democracy, humanism and human rights. MORE.

Tracker Pixel for Entry


View our privacy policy and terms of service.