Ten years ago, Sean and Linda Samuels moved to Irvine, home to both a Chabad center and the Modern Orthodox Beth Jacob Congregation, along with other synagogues.
As the couple grew more observant and had children, they wanted the family to be part of their journey, which, of course, included weekly walks to shul.
But how? Irvine had no eruv, an unbroken boundary that uses existing electrical lines and fencing to encircle a synagogue and neighboring homes, which, according to rabbinic law, encloses a "private" space where observant Jews may carry objects on the Sabbath and other Jewish holidays. Without an eruv, people who need to carry, or push strollers or wheelchairs, are stranded at home.
Sean Samuels, a Beth Jacob board member, was instrumental in the quest to erect Irvine's eruv, which should be operational by Rosh Hashanah. His initiative underscores Irvine's reputation for welcoming people of many faiths and how the Orthodox community aims for inclusiveness.
At least eight others eruvs are in the works around Southern California, too, a reflection of observant communities taking hold outside urban areas. With an estimated 5-mile perimeter, Irvine's boundary is a triangle bordered by the San Diego Freeway between the Michaelson and University exits, and University and Harvard avenues.
"It's going to make Irvine this whole new playground," said Samuels, who still needed to raise two-thirds of the eruv's projected cost, $27,000.
"Having an eruv is a huge attraction," he said, claiming property values will increase within its boundaries because of demand by observant Jews. Howard Shapiro, the project manager of a 50-mile perimeter eruv in West Los Angeles completed in January 2003, is now consulting on eight projects regionally. Most are on the scale of Irvine's, he said.
"An eruv becomes another sign the community is coming of age," said Rabbi Alan Kalinsky, the West Coast director of the Orthodox Union, whose members are Modern Orthodox synagogues. "It's a very important sign that people don't look singularly in Pico-Robertson and North Hollywood," he said, where eruvs have existed for at least 20 years.
The number of observant Jews and their proportion among American Jewry appears to be increasing, as does the potential for municipal clashes over eruvs.
An eruv is a modern phenomenon, Kalinsky said, which was unnecessary in Europe's walled cities and enclosed ghettos, but were erected beginning 40 years ago in the New York area. The highest-profile and longest-running eruv battle divided Jew against Jew and sparked charges of anti-Semitism in Tenafly, N.J. Although the resulting court case focused on the legality of allowing a religious use of public property, proponents say the eruv's critics, including some Reform Jews, exploited the constitution to bar Orthodox Jews from their neighborhood. Opponents of the eruv said their opposition was not based in anti-Semitism, rather in the fact that Orthodox Jews often spoiled community endeavors, such as public schooling (they send their children to private school) and local politics (they don't participate).
Orange County's Jewish denominations lack the rancor seen in Tenafly and other Eastern cities, said Benjamin Hubbard, chair of Cal State Fullerton's comparative religions department. "Here, there is not the same history of bad will; interreligious feuding is the nastiest kind," he said.
Without dissent, the eruv was approved on the consent calendar by the Irvine City Council on July 13. Even so, the project took two years to complete because of the number of public and private entities involved, including supervision by an eruv authority, Rabbi Gershon Bess of the Rabbinic Council of California, whose members are Orthodox rabbis. Besides stringing fishing line between 58 Edison poles, Bess required installation of five new poles and the addition of four poles to existing fences.
Samuels said Irvine's Chabad is considering expanding the eruv to encircle its location in Woodbridge. The Chabad's Rabbi Alter Tanenbaum could not be reached for comment.
While in some areas of Los Angeles an eruv tended to buoy property values in a flat market, Ethyl Krawitz is uncertain Irvine will experience such a phenomenon. "It's only appealing to the very observant; it means nothing to anyone else," said Krawitz, a RE/MAX Realtor in Irvine whose clientele is 80 percent Jewish.
Irvine's new Jewish Community Center already is a more potent magnet, she said. Krawitz sees the JCC's location influence housing decisions of people relocating to the area, as well as Jews relocating internally from Anaheim, Orange and San Juan Capistrano.
"It's a wonderful draw," she said.
To maintain the eruv, the line's integrity will be checked weekly. Once the eruv is up, results will be disseminated by e-mail and at www.irvineeruv.org. For more information, e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org.
We welcome your feedback.
Your information will not be shared or sold without your consent. Get all the details.
Terms of Service
JewishJournal.com has rules for its commenting community.Get all the details.
JewishJournal.com reserves the right to use your comment in our weekly print publication.