April 12, 2001
Parents searching for an "alternative" circumcision find one mohels call bogus.
An undeniable physical reminder of a man's connection to Judaism, circumcision has been an important focus of the first days of a boy's life since before we received the Torah. However, for almost as long, there have been people who question the act of circumcision and those who have rallied for eliminating the practice.
Modern times are no exception. In fact, through televised programs and numerous Web sites, the anti-circumcision movement is gaining increased exposure and coverage.
Though most Jewish families still choose to circumcise their sons, some parents are looking for alternatives to their baby boy's tearful parting with his foreskin. Often, these parents are torn between sparing their child the pain of circumcision and maintaining a connection with Jewish traditions and commandments.
As central as the mitzvah of circumcision is to Judaism, some parents have created alternative rituals. One such ceremony is called brit shalom, or covenant of wholeness, during which parents might read Bible passages and recite the traditional blessing normally recited at a brit milah, but there is no circumcision performed.
Another procedure called hatafat dam brit is also being used in place of a circumcision. Usually only appropriate in the case of already circumcised converts or adopted babies, or when a baby is mistakenly circumcised at the hospital, hatafat dam brit is a Jewish ritual circumcision performed by drawing a drop of blood from the site of the circumcision.
Dr. Fred Kogan, a prominent mohel in the Los Angeles area, is concerned about the increasing number of requests he is getting for this ritual. "People don't want to circumcise during this big anti-circumcision movement and are looking for something to take its place," he says. "People have been calling me now, saying, 'We think it's barbaric, horrific, and we don't want to do this to our child.'" He adds that, on the other hand, parents may want to placate grandparents, and many don't want to exclude themselves from the Jewish world.
In reality, there is no alternative to circumcision, Kogan maintains. "Circumcision is a cultural, physical sign," he says. "It's something you have to go through if you want to be part of the team."
Rabbi Yehuda Lebovics, a Los Angeles Orthodox mohel, has not received many requests for circumcision alternatives, but he is quick to dismiss the appropriateness of hatafat dam brit. "It is totally invalid, totally meaningless. The only way that the drop of blood is valid is if there is no foreskin." Otherwise, he says, "It is just a waste of a drop of blood."
Rabbi Dennis Eisner, L.A. director of the Berit Milah Program (a joint project of the Central Conference of American Rabbis, Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion, where he is assistant dean, and the Union of American Hebrew Congregations) is in contact with mohels throughout the world. Regarding invalid applications of hatafat dam brit, he says, "I don't think it's very widespread. ... There may be people out there who are trying to appease parents, but those people are wrong. They are doing a disservice to the young men who are entering in the community. It is not what we're about, not what we're promoting, and not what we're suggesting." Though he recognizes that the once-asserted medical benefits of circumcision are now falling into doubt, Eisner does not see this as relevant to the Jewish act of brit milah. "There is some ambivalence about the medical act of circumcision, but we are not about the medical act of circumcision," he says, but about entering into a covenant with God.
Leaders in the anti-circumcision movement say the number of Jewish parents looking for alternatives to circumcision is rising. Ronald Goldman, author of "Questioning Circumcision -- A Jewish Perspective" and director of the Circumcision Resource Center in Boston, Mass., says, "The large majority of Jews are not aware of the religious reasons" for circumcision "and do so for cultural reasons."
Goldman, who does not see his ideas as a threat to modern Judaism, says his book is not directed at traditional Jews. "We are not here to tell people what to do, but to provide an alternative. We're here to support Jews who are questioning circumcision, to let them know they are not alone. ... We have been contacted by hundreds of Jews who are questioning circumcision. We're also here to clear up the myths and misunderstandings about circumcision." Goldman calls into question whether one really needs to be circumcised to be Jewish, suggesting that one only needs to be born to a Jewish mother. He adds that circumcision is in direct violation of the Torah's prohibition against self-mutilation.
Rabbi Mark Fasman of Temple Sinai in Westwood says, "These points are dealt with extensively by the rabbis." While there are laws against self-mutilation, circumcision is considered the removal of something that is not necessary, he explains, comparing the foreskin to the unneeded parts of a fruit. "It's important at one stage, but it is ultimately not part of the fruit, like the stem of an apple." Fasman says, "Human beings don't own their bodies; God owns their bodies," adding that it is God who is commanding us to circumcise.
Fasman sees the modern hesitations about circumcision as partly due to our rights-based society. "Rights is a whole new language, and it is often at direct odds with standard Jewish thought. We are inheritors of the rabbinic tradition, which is [that] we best fulfill our obligations in this world. We best fulfill our obligation through the performance of mitzvot."
According to Anita Diamant in "The Jewish Baby Book," the Torah refers to the foreskin as the orlah, which, she says, "means not only foreskin but also any barrier standing in the way of beneficial results. The word orlah is also used as a metaphor for obstructions of the heart that prevent a person from hearing or understanding God. Removing the orlah is interpreted as a permanent, physical sign of dedication to the ongoing task of perfecting the self in order to be closer to the Holy One."
All parents of Jewish boys feel anxiety about their sons' discomfort during the bris, but most accept it as part of being Jewish and as something the baby gets through. While Jewish parents seeking alternatives to circumcision are few, Kogan fears it's a growing trend. "When anything starts, people say, 'Eh, it's nothing.' But if I had three people call me in the past three years, and none in the previous 14 years, there must be a lot more people out there."