Of all the incendiary books that have been written about Israel over the last year or so, none is quite as fiery as "Israel: The Will to Prevail" by Danny Danon (Palgrave Macmillan: $26).
Danon is a young activist in the Likud Party and serves as deputy speaker of the Knesset. He agrees with the various critics and commentators on the left on only a single point: "We are now at a critical juncture in our brief but momentous history," Danon writes, "and our very survival is once again at stake." Unlike Peter Beinart or Jeremy Ben-Ami, however, Danon rejects the notion that the United States (or, by implication, American Jews) is entitled to tell Israel how to conduct its affairs.
"Israel must take firm hold of its own destiny, with a ready willingness to act decisively on its own behalf," he insists. "[H]istory shows that when we act on our own, according to our own best interests, the results are not only better for Israel but for world peace as a whole."
Lest anyone mistake his political colors, however, Danon pointedly insists on using the words "Jewish communities" and "residents of these communities" in place of "settlers" and "settlements." The West Bank, of course, is referred to as Judea and Samaria. "The Jewish people’s claim to Israel," he writes, "is older and stronger than any other people’s in the history of the world." Indeed, Danon presents his fierce little book as nothing less than "a road map for Jewish victory — achieved with or without backing from her allies."
Danon insists that it is in the strategic best interest of the United States to support Israel, by which he plainly means the hard-line policies of Likud. "It’s an unfortunate fact that Israel has grown more distant from the United States," he writes, "and I believe this puts both our countries in peril." And he cites President Barack Obama, Vice President Joe Biden and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton as advocates of what he calls "the growing acceptance in the United States and abroad of a left-wing, so-called progressive position on Israel" and "a one-sided view of Palestinian aspirations."
"Discomforting behavior continues to come from the White House, which makes Israelis wonder whether the United States is really on our side," Danon writes, "and strengthens the case that we must be confident to take matters, when necessary, in our own hands despite world or U.S. opinion."
Nowadays, of course, the demarcation between left and right is blurry. Who, after all, would disagree with Danon’s assertion that "Israel’s experience with Gaza demonstrates the folly of those who say that the only pathway to peace involves handing over our land to the Palestinians." Yet Danon also insists on salting his prose with fighting words — "our land" is a phrase that simply ignores the fundamental question of where the boundary is to be drawn between Arabs and Jews. Even when he claims that he "actively welcome[s] a healthy debate on the subject of Israel and the United States," it is hard to discern where "healthy debate" leaves off and "criticism that demonizes Israel" begins.
The conclusion he reaches is that Israel cannot afford to take the risk of a compromise with the Palestinians: "Over and over again," he complains, "Israelis are exhorted to concede more and more, while the Arabs are only asked to stop incitement and killing." And, crucially, he argues that "any manufactured claim to a Palestinian state" is trumped by the inevitability that "such an entity would be a serious and ongoing threat for Israel."
Danon calls instead for "a three-state solution," an antique approach to peace-making in the Middle East that would assign sovereignty over the Palestinians to Israel, Jordan and Egypt. Clearly, his plan is not likely to succeed, and I suspect that’s the real reason why he advocates it: "Before we can make the three-state solution a reality," he warns, Israel must be afforded "real recognition" by the existing states, and "Israel must take on and defeat those who are against us — Hamas, Hezbollah, and others."
"Israel: The Will to Prevail" leaves me in exactly the same place I found myself after reading books by his adversaries in the progressive wing of Zionism — it’s a locked room in which the doors and windows are only a trompe l’oeil on solid walls. How Israel and the Jewish people are to extricate themselves from our unhappy predicament remains unexplained.
Kirsch, author and publishing attorney, is the book editor of The Jewish Journal. His next book is "The Short, Strange Life of Herschel Grynszpan: A Boy Avenger, a Nazi Diplomat, and a Murder in Paris," which will be published in 2013 under the Horace Liveright imprint of W. W. Norton to coincide with the 75th anniversary year of Kristallnacht.