April 13, 2006
Spectator - Spin-Doctors of the Revolution
Rachel Boynton, director of the documentary "Our Brand Is Crisis," was excited when she first learned that American political consultants export their work globally.
While a student at Columbia School of Journalism, she saw a film about the history of 20th century nonviolent conflict that included a segment on how American consultants had gone to Chile in 1990 to produce TV ads for a successful campaign to end Gen. Augusto Pinochet's long autocratic presidency.
"I thought to myself, 'There's my movie. I want to follow an American who is trying to run an ad campaign to oust a dictator,'" Boynton said in a telephone interview. "It seemed to epitomize a lot of things I think of as being fundamentally American -- optimism, hubris, political idealism and the profit motive all wrapped up in one event."
Raised by her Jewish lawyer mother, Esther, after her parents divorced when she was 9 months old, Boynton had already lived in Washington, D.C., Los Angeles, Denver, Ann Arbor and Paris by the time she was in graduate school. Her film's subject also dovetailed with her undergraduate degree in international relations from Brown University.
After five years of work on "Crisis," Boynton, 32, has finally completed her movie, which opens in Los Angeles on April 14. But it didn't turn out as originally planned.
She documents the campaign waged by the liberal firm of Greenberg Carville (as in James Carville) Shrum (GCS) on behalf of the unpopular but reformist millionaire, Gonzalo Sanchez de Lozada (a.k.a. "Goni"), who was attempting to return to office as president of Bolivia.
"I liked GCS because they were very idealistic about what they did," Boynton said. "Most people expect to see political consultants being very mercenary. This firm professed to be idealistic about their work."
Essentially the firm's strategies for advertising, focus groups, polling and image-shaping worked in Bolivia. "Goni" won in 2002. But the rifts caused by the spirited election set in motion a bloody uprising that forced him to flee from office in 2004.
The turn of events left the firm's Jeremy Rosner and Stan Greenberg -- captured by Boynton in post-revolt interviews -- feeling melancholy and disappointed. A revolution was not part of their plans.
"They had this American attitude because we live in a place that's stable," Boynton said. "That is not necessarily the normal course of things all across the world. We need to recognize our perspective is not universally shared."
"Our Brand Is Crisis" opens April 14 at the Laemmle Sunset 5, 8000 Sunset Blvd., West Hollywood. For showtimes, call (323) 848-3500.