August 3, 2006
Letters to the Editor
I write to you out of deep concern regarding the Bush administration's failure to meet the challenge of dealing with the violence in the Middle East (Cover Story, July 21).
Secretary of State [Condoleeza] Rice went to Rome with violence raging in southern Lebanon and Gaza, and missiles raining on northern Israel. She left Rome without any plan for improving the situation or preventing further escalation.
The United States held off intervening in this conflict for far too long, with the administration arguing that it would not engage until the moment was right for success. But having decided that the moment had come, and with so much at stake for America, Israel, Lebanon and the entire region, Secretary Rice should have left Rome with something in hand.
We expect more from American diplomacy.
Rabbi Neil Comess-Daniels
Standing With Israel
I urge that you seek to maintain Jewish unity in these days of crisis. Deference to the Jewish Left is divisive. Ignore it. You have a job to do to maintain Jewish morale. I'm an octogenerian and I don't expect to be here too long. Israel must be victorious. I'm expecting to see it. Am Ysroel Chai.
While Rabbi Lisa Edwards is free to reinterpret Leviticus to advocate that which the Bible specifically forbids, it is specious of her to argue that it is "causeless hatred" for Torah-true Jerusalemites to protest the deliberate provocation that her colleagues attempted to foist on the Holy City ("Commemorating Sorrows," July 28).
One could contend it is "causeless hatred" to foist ones agenda on others.
Response to Michael Steinhardt
Michael Steinhardt ("It May Be Time to Change Goals, Ideas on Philanthropy," July 28) suggested that the decline in Jewish philanthropy during that past 20 years is due to a "loss of connection to Jewish roots."
When I consider this problem and its cause, I think of an address by Dr. Jacob Neusner given at Yale in 2000 ("If Ideas Mattered: The Intellectual Crisis of Jewish-American Life").
Regarding the problem, Neusner states:
"Having used up the intellectual capital of a half-century ago, American Jewry has run out of ideas. It debates matters of practicality, issues of mere continuity. It argues about how to persuade the coming generation to continue the received enterprise of Jewry, not how to assess the worth and truth of that enterprise."
Regarding the cause, Neusner states:
"Where does the blame lie? It lies with the rabbinical seminaries that have produced a rabbinate without Torah. The rabbinical schools are somnolent; not much happens in them. The rabbinical seminaries are backwaters, out of the mainstream of contemporary Judaic debate."
Jews will reconnect to the community if and when our institutions and leaders offer relevant and compelling reasons to do so.
Marsha Plafkin Hurwitz
Make a Match
I read with interest the July 28 article "Matchmaker, Matchmaker Make Me a Donation Match" regarding Joseph Hyman's new Center for Entrepreneurial Philanthropy and its description as both "revolutionary" and charting "a new course."
Knowing The Jewish Journal endeavors to be a resource to its readers, I was certain you'd want to know that while Hyman's initiative may be novel or the first of its kind on the East Coast, that's certainly not the case here on the West Coast. A similar resource has existed locally since 2001 in the form of the Family Foundation Center within the Jewish Community Foundation of Los Angeles. Our organization created the center, directed by Susan Grinel, specifically to assist funders -- whether they are a donor at the Jewish Community Foundation or not -- with maximizing the impact of their philanthropic endeavors.
The center offers comprehensive services and programs that enable funders to identify their charitable passions and prioritize their grantmaking, selecting causes and issues that resonate with them at a personal level. Its educational offerings, provided by national philanthropic experts particularly in the highly topical area of intergenerational giving, enlighten families on how to effectively stimulate and involve their children and grandchildren in charitable pursuits.
In this vein, the center organizes the annual Community Youth Foundation, through which selected high-school students learn how to identify and research worthy charitable programs, conduct field studies and then, as a committee, dispense $10,000 in grants funded by The Foundation.
Perhaps most importantly, since its inception, the center has helped to facilitate the distribution of millions of charitable dollars to causes locally, as well as in Israel, through its advisory work with funders.
I applaud Hyman's good work. We are only on the forward edge of enlightening, educating and spurring passionate, committed philanthropists to sustain Jewish causes at home and in Israel. Much work still lies ahead.
Marvin I. Schotland
Tell Robert Jaffee that his article on Jamie McCourt had an error ("Jamie McCourt Proves She's an Artful Dodger President," July 21): Cesar Izturis has been with the Dodgers for more than three years. Remember, it's "speed and accuracy."
By the way, does Izturis mean "I have problems" in Yiddish?
We are all deeply saddened by the tragic loss of 4 UN Observers in South Lebanon, and in Ireland we think of the 48 men we lost there in our long commitment from 1978 to 2001, one of whom, Pvt. Kevin Joyce, has never been returned for burial by his Hezbollah kidnappers.
Two points are worth recalling at this point.
Firstly, Canada lost four men in 2002 in Afghanistan due to mistaken fire by a U.S. pilot, and the Israelis have also lost men [in both Gaza and Lebanon] recently at the hands of their own forces. In Ireland, our Gardai in their crack SWAT "Emergency Response Unit" have also known such mishaps, and in Northern Ireland, many such tragic incidents happened, with RUC killing one RUC officer and two army; while the British Army accidentally killed one each from the RUC, RUC Reserve and UDR -- and seven of their own. That is 13 such deaths.
These incidents, like many involving civilian losses close to military targets, occur either due to the unavoidable "fog of war," or to human or equipment failure. However tragic, they are not malicious.
Secondly, the distinguished, recently retired Canadian Maj-Gen Lewis W. Mac Kenzie, 66, a veteran of nine U.N. tours, and U.N. chief of staff in 1992 in Yugoslavia at the time of the Siege of Sarajevo, wrote a book in 1993, "Peacekeeper," about his experience. He was a friend and former Battalion colleague of the Canadian U.N. Observer who lost his life, and received a recent e-mail from this colleague that Hezbollah were firing from close to that UN post. Such an experienced and senior witness as MacKenzie is indeed credible. That information explains how this tragedy could happen, and also recalls the recent comment of Jan Egeland of the UN about Hezbollah's "cowardly blending" with the civilians population.
Such abusing of unarmed U.N. Observers, women and children by Hezbollah is not new, and their primary responsibility needs to be fully recognized.
I know that some children in Lebanon have been killed and others wounded and for that I am truly sorry. However, I am very tired of hearing about innocent Lebanese civilians. Let's face the facts. The Lebanese are in violation of U.N. Resolution 1559, which says that the Lebanese government is to dismantle terrorist groups such as Hezbollah. Not only was this not done but Hezbollah members were voted into government offices by the "innocent" people.
Even now, when they are having their lives disrupted by the conflict, they support Hezbollah. I have not heard one person being interviewed in Lebanon condemn Hezbollah for starting the conflict. They blame Israel: Israel should have released 1,000 prisoners for the two kidnapped soldiers. Israel should forget about the soldiers and the 17-year-old boy who were murdered by Hezbollah. Israel should not have responded to the rockets being fired into major cities forcing innocent Israelis into bomb shelters and killing and wounding others. Not a word about the fact that Hezbollah started the conflict and is hiding out in populated areas using the Lebanese civilians as shields. How innocent are people who support terrorists?
Tobi Ruth Love
Thank you for the very powerful cover photo of the Israeli soldiers and "moment of truth. (Cover story, July 20). we have copies up in our offices and have made copies for many people. Please God this picture will inspire people to say tehilim (our secret weapon) to help Israel. And, we hope that this cover photo begins a time of more substantive, positive Jewish content in your paper.
The dismantling of the Iranian proxy, Hezbollah, would be a major blow against global terrorism, rogue states Syria and Iran and possibly even Iran's nuclear plans. But, if Hezbollah emerges intact as a fighting force, Israel and the global war on terrorism would suffer significantly. Saudi Arabia (and other moderate Arab states) issued a rare condemnation of Hezbollah as they fear the ramifications of it's strength. Much of the Middle East has been engulfed by Islamic radicalism. Israel must remain strong as Democracy's bulwark against the tide.
I enjoy your weekly Torah reading and particularly the various interpretations of the text that are given by rabbis of differing denominations. I was very disappointed in last week's column by Rabbi Joshua Grater who essentially used the Torah as a political attack on the president and his policies ("Power of Vows," July 21). I feel that this is not appropriate.
The Journal provides many articles about politics from various points of view. For many of your readers, I am certain that this weekly column provides the only, or at least one of few, Torah education opportunities. People who are not knowledgeable are left with the impression that the Torah has given its imprimatur to this rabbi's politics.
"How can we trust a leader who lies in regard to the highest level of commitment, war and Peace?"
When Howard Dean says this sort of thing, people expect it of him. When a rabbi publicly calls someone a liar in the name of the Torah, this only demeans the status of the rabbinate and the Torah itself in many eyes.
The Sages write that there are 70 "faces" to the Torah, implying that there are many ways to interpret the written word. I would not like to see your usually excellent column be lowered to the level of "dueling rabbis." Your readers are, for the most part, well-educated and intelligent. The rabbi should make his point and let the reader draw his own conclusions. Let's try to use the Torah as a unifying force in our community rather than a divisive one and save the politics for columns that are labeled "Political Commentary" rather than "Torah Portion."
Dr. George Lebovitz
It seems that Rabbi Joshua Levine Grater should take his own counsel. In his article he writes that he and his wife are trying to teach their children the power of words, both positive and negative, and "the power of the word is what matters here." Yet just a few paragraphs later he libels our public leaders.
As a rabbi, he is undoubtedly aware of the Jewish prohibition against lashon hara, including the injunction against speaking negatively about someone, even when true. When I reflected back on his article after having read it the first time, I thought that he had made the statement, "Bush lied." It was only after rereading that I discovered that those words were not part of what he had written, though the message was so clear that my memory told me otherwise.
He continued by stating that the federal government made false promises during the Katrina Crisis, and bragged about the local Board of Rabbis of Southern California. So what's so wrong with people taking care of people? We certainly can't expect the federal government to do it all. That is the beauty of communities, with people helping people.
Rebecca J. Evers
JewishJournal.com is produced by TRIBE Media Corp., a non-profit media company whose mission is to inform, connect and enlighten community