Quantcast

Jewish Journal

JewishJournal.com

January 19, 2006

Letters

http://www.jewishjournal.com/letters_to_the_editor/article/letters_20060120

Focus Attention

"After reflecting for a few painful and difficult days, I feel I should address some mistatements I made ("Uncertain Time for Likud in America", 1/13/06)." Rather than spending precious resources on the symptoms of intermarriage, I was trying to focus attention on support for Israel as a basis of instilling Jewish identity.

The Jewish lay leaders and rabbis I know wholeheartedly love and support Israel and are instilling Jewish identity in our entire diverse community. In addition, all Jews, no matter what their sexual orientation, as well as Jews by choice, are sincere and dedicated Jews and should be respected. I sincerely apologize for the comments reflecting otherwise.

Myles L. Berman
Los Angeles

Great Cover

I applaud your great cover of Jan. 6 ("L.A.'s Top 10 Menches). It does not matter to me if you call these outstanding examples "menchen" or "menches." What I find very important is that your cover and inside story focused on people doing great things for others.

Many times I find that the covers reflect a sensational aspect more in keeping with a magazine at a market checkout stand, than a vibrant Jewish community. Keep covering positive issues. Thank you

Esther Tabak
Beverly Hills

Wow! What a great choice for your [Jan. 6] cover. The Orthodox Jewish community is grateful to you for highlighting Avi Leibovic and the extraordinary work he does. The other community lights were an inspiration, and choosing among these heroes for the cover must have been a challenge.

Nevertheless, your choice was much appreciated as the Aish Tamid program has truly established itself as a essential and effective community resource.

Rabbi Meyer H. May
Los Angeles

Orthodox Women

As Amy Klein reported, the Friday night panel of the OU convention indeed featured a robust exchange concerning the place of women within Orthodoxy ("Orthodox but Not Monolithic," Jan. 6). Though my views on the issue were described by as being "far left," I would imagine that many readers would find them to be quite consistent with mainstream ethical and Jewish religious thought.

These views (all of which have been translated into practice at B'nai David-Judea) are a rooted in the fundamental idea that women should be able to exercise all of the religious opportunities that the halacha provides them with.

These include the opportunity to carry, dance with and (in a women's service) read from the Sefer Torah; to pray in a women's section that is an exact mirror image of the men's section; to study Talmud without restrictions or limitations; to recite Kaddish for a deceased parent, and to be chosen for any position of lay leadership for which they are qualified.

If indeed there are "far left" views, then I suppose I must humbly accept this label.

Rabbi Yosef Kanefsky
B'nai David-Judea

I write in response to Amy Klein's thoughtful article on "Orthodox but Not Monolithic." While your reporter generally presented both the spirit and the substance of my remarks on the issue of women in Orthodox Jewish communal life, I was misquoted as stating that no women currently serve on the board of the Orthodox Union.

While I noted that there are currently no women officers in the Orthodox Union, I did not suggest that there aren't any women board members. I know better than that. My wife, Vivian, is one of the most active members of the Orthodox Union's board of governors.

David Luchins
National Vice President
Orthodox Union

Westchester's Bright Future

While I thank The Jewish Journal for commenting on B'nai Tikvah's commitment to the Westchester community, I have to take issue with the statement: "The expanding airport and white flight reduced the once-thriving synagogue to a skeletal congregation" ("Still Strong in Westchester," Jan. 6).

Our congregation is tightly woven with 100-plus families. We have actually bucked the trend by increasing our membership by over 10 percent since Reb Jason joined us. Our award-winning nursery school is going strong, and our religious school boasts over 40 children. The future is very bright for this "skeletal congregation."

Art Wexler
Westchester

Links

Thank you for your very brave and truthful article, "Too Jewish to Play Myself" (Dec. 16, 2005). Hollywood's weak link to reality is driving Jewish and non-Jewish actresses nuts. There seems to be a general dislike of what is really female, even including female old age. So go forth and be a strong link and seek other strong links; create a new Hollywood. There are many of us on your side.

Theresa Merrin
Thousand Oaks

'Singlehood'

Thank you. Each week when I take The Jewish Journal, I always begin by reading the back page singles section. The singles section is my corner, even when I don't like what someone writes, it still gives me food for thought about my own experiences of "singlehood" in Los Angles. While I often relate to the experiences of the columnists, I don't often relate to their philosophies.

How refreshing it was to read Mark Miller's thought ("Unhappy New Year!" Jan. 6). No, I am not desperate. Yes, I am living. Dating is about feeling comfortable in our own skin, leading an active social life, which can include, but is not limited to, attending cultural events and volunteering opportunities and meeting people along the way.

So thank you for the fresh perspective. It's nice knowing that I am not alone in how I live out my "singlehood."

Deborah Graetz
via e-mail

Reaction to Rosove

Rabbi John Rosove in his opinion, "IRS Errs on Endorsing Candidate Charge" (Jan. 6), commits an error of omission in not sharing with your readers how most of his congregants reacted to his extraordinary erev Rosh Hashanah sermon. Yes, undoubtedly a few congregants were alarmed that his "speaking truth to power" could threaten the temple's 501(c)(3) status.

But the vast majority in the sanctuary responded very differently. They heard his prophetic reminder that Jewish values and traditions speak to our communal responsibility for caring for "those who are in the shadow of life." They understood it to be a call to action, and they applauded!

Marjorie B. Green
Los Angeles

Sharon's Legacy

Rob Eshman seems bewildered by the rehabilitation of Sharon's legacy ("Scheinerman/Sharon," Jan. 13). He doesn't clarify that Sharon was truly despised by the Muslims and the European, as well as the Jewish left. History has proven that Sharon was ahead of the curve: He was the first true counterrorist leader, and worst of all, he was successful.

Though Eshman considers the Lebanon incursion to be a "disaster," he is only viewing it from the point of view of Israeli public relations. The true reality was, in fact, a disaster for the PLO, whose murderous rampages in the Lebanese civil war against Christian, as well as Muslim Shiite Arabs, and cross-border rocket attacks against northern Israel came to a crashing halt as Sharon exiled Arafat and the Palestinian leadership to Tunisia.

It is no coincidence that bin Laden has repeatedly harped on this fact in his diatribes. Ariel Sharon was more accurate in his assessment of future threats to Israel than the Western world was to the threat of Islamo-fascism. He should be credited for this in his legacy,

Richard Friedman
Los Angeles

 

JewishJournal.com is produced by TRIBE Media Corp., a non-profit media company whose mission is to inform, connect and enlighten community
through independent journalism. TRIBE Media produces the 150,000-reader print weekly Jewish Journal in Los Angeles – the largest Jewish print
weekly in the West – and the monthly glossy Tribe magazine (TribeJournal.com). Please support us by clicking here.

© Copyright 2014 Tribe Media Corp.
All rights reserved. JewishJournal.com is hosted by Nexcess.net
Web Design & Development by Hop Studios 0.2021 / 37