March 25, 2004
Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's impending visit to Israel could be a win-win for the governor, the Los Angeles Jewish community and for Israel, but first some fine-tuning is in order.
As we reported last week, the governor is scheduled to travel to Jerusalem May 2 to participate in groundbreaking ceremonies there for the $150 million Center for Human Dignity-Museum of Tolerance.
But as soon as reports circulated that the visit was on, eyebrows started shooting skyward. By the middle of this week, it looked like the governor's trip to the Land of Milk and Honey was going to include a side order of sour grapes.
Why, asked some local Jews, did such a high-profile visit seem to exclude representation of a wider swath of the California Jewish community? Why should one Jewish organization take up the bulk of the governor's agenda? Why was a trip by a politician not organized first through the normal political channels?
"He's not some star popping in to help out some friends," said one local activist, clearly disgruntled. "He's the governor of the State of California visiting the State of Israel." (This trip is privately funded, and does not use taxpayers' money.)
Some of the concerns found their way into a March 24 Los Angeles Times article about the trip. The story, with its implication that the trip was stepping on toes and upsetting protocol, infuriated some Wiesenthal Center supporters.
"I don't get it," one of them told me. "Here this popular governor is going to Israel at a time when Israel really needs all the friends it can get, and people are turning it into an issue. I've had it with the Jews."
You know emotions are running hot when Museum of Tolerance supporters start getting anti-Semitic.
But, exasperated joking aside, the Jerusalem brouhaha does threaten to mar what can be a flat-out success for all parties. So far, the mess is hardly anything that the governor's office can't quickly clean up. One experienced local pol -- not Jewish -- observed the dust-up with dispassion: "Arnold has a mix of politically experienced and politically inexperienced people on his payroll," he said.
When it comes to little things like visits to foreign countries, experience helps.
Simon Wiesenthal Center dean and founder Rabbi Marvin Hier, who initiated the Jerusalem museum project, said he just can't comprehend some of the reports and rumors that are circulating about the visit.
Most disturbing is the idea that the visit is some kind of quid pro quo. In the heat of the bitter recall campaign that put Schwarzenegger in office, Hier reiterated the results of a Wiesenthal Center investigation that cleared the Austrian-born governor's late father, Gustav Schwarzenegger, of involvement in any World War II-era war crimes.
If the trip is seen as payback, it demeans both the governor and the center. "Quid pro quo applies when you don't know a person," Hier told me by phone. "I've known the governor for 20 years. He has had cocktail parties and parlor meetings for us. He has donated hundreds of thousands of dollars to us and raised millions. He has participated in events of much less importance than [the groundbreaking], so it would be unusual if he didn't participate in this."
Furthermore, Hier added, the center released all records it found pertaining to Schwarzenegger's father to the media for public review.
The idea for trip is a year and a half old, Hier said. Schwarzenegger attended a parlor meeting in Miami for the Jerusalem museum long before his run for governor. At that meeting, Schwarzenegger promised to attend.
"He said, 'You don't have to tell me I'm going, I'm going,'" Hier said.
There has not been any indication that the recent State Department travel advisory against Israel and the prospect of violence in the wake of the assassination of Shiekh Ahmed Yassin will deter the governor. A spokesperson at the governor's office said that trip was still in the planning stages, as are responses to security concerns.
"Everything is still being determined," the spokesperson said.
As to whether the Wiesenthal Center should have made sure to bring Israelis and local Jewish leaders in on the trip, Hier said he could only take responsibility for the part of the visit that concerned the groundbreaking ceremony and a Museum of Tolerance fundraising dinner that the governor was scheduled to attend. (The governor's office would not confirm his attendance at the latter event.)
"I assume he has other components to his trip," Hier said. "We've always known he was going to do other things."
All official visits by governors include a meeting with the prime minister -- true whether the governor is from California or Kansas -- and a visit to the Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial and museum. (The Museum of Tolerance, which is being designed by Frank Gehry, will have no Holocaust-related exhibit.)
"My interest is that the governor is going to have an official, formal element to his visit to Israel," Israel Consul General Yuval Rotem said. The governor's office said an itinerary is still in formation, and its release is two to three weeks off.
"Of course that should take place," said Hier, referring to a meeting between Schwarzenegger and the prime minister, "but I'm not involved in that."
Including other community leaders in the festivities surrounding the groundbreaking was not an option, Hier said. Invitees are people whom the center hopes will contribute toward the $200 million price tag of the museum and its endowment. So far, the center has raised $75 million for the project.
"On this occasion the shoe didn't fit," Hier said. "We're looking for prospects."
It's no secret that a dram or two of bad blood has flowed between the Wiesenthal Center and some quarters of the community ever since Hier established the center and the museum here. As the center has become more of a presence in Jewish Los Angeles -- many in the media see it as the major Jewish presence here -- Hier and other Jewish leaders have worked to forge warmer bonds. Indeed, not everyone is ticked. "I think it's fine," said Mel Levine, chairman of the Jewish Community Relations Council of The Jewish Federation, regarding the trip. Levine, himself a former congressman, did not think a promise made as a private citizen should necessarily be negated once in public service.
"The governor, long before he was governor, was a supporter of the Museum of Tolerance here," he said, "and I believe it's good whenever public officials go to Israel."
Officially, then, many community leaders are adopting a far-from-antagonistic approach to the visit. They want the governor, in the words of one activist, to see that "there's more to the Jewish community than Marvin Hier," but they also don't want to create any ill will so early in the administration. That makes sense. There are just too many important communal issues -- poverty relief, medical funding, homeland security, to name a few -- that rate higher on the agenda than this visit.
They also understand that, to borrow from the season we're fast approaching, this governor is different from all other governors. "He doesn't see himself as a politician," said the local pol, "and so far people don't see him as one." Just as Schwarzenegger's campaign circumvented normal channels of campaigning, so too his governance can bend the rules.
But as the governor moves forward, it must be with an understanding that as good a friend as he has in Hier, he has the potential to make many more in the Jewish community.
JewishJournal.com is produced by TRIBE Media Corp., a non-profit media company whose mission is to inform, connect and enlighten community