Quantcast

Jewish Journal

Letters Clarifying Remarks

June 26, 1997 | 8:00 pm

I am very grateful for Ari Noonan's coverage of the inter-denominational town meeting that took place at UCLA Hillel last month ("Setting a Conciliatory Tone," June 20). I feel a need, however, to fill out Mr. Noonan's description of my remarks that evening.

As the article makes clear, I am an unapologetic proponent of inter-denominational respect and cooperation, and I stressed that theme at the Hillel forum. I also emphasized though, that it is my own belief that Orthodoxy in fact represents the most accurate expression of Judaism, and that I would never advise my congregants that non-Orthodox expressions are equally acceptable personal options. I asserted further, that both of my colleagues on the panel would feel the same way about their own movements. All three of us had chosen our respective movements because we believed that they were more valid than the others are. I then suggested that this reality is the framework for our pursuit of finding our common ground and working together on common problems -- a process that will benefit all of klal yisrael.

I admire my friend Ari Noonan's enthusiasm for the "good news" on inter-denominational relations. And I'm proud to be a part of that good news. The realities within which we must operate must also be clear if our endeavor will in fact bring success and blessing.

Rabbi Yosef Kanefsky

B'nai David-Judea Congregation

Los Angeles


Amplifying Comments

Not at all surprising, because he is a most articulate professional journalist, who objectively does his research and then writes very accurate pieces, Ari Noonan provides all of his readers some thought-provoking comments regarding diversity and pluralism in the Jewish community, and the difficulty some ultra-traditionalists have in coping with this reality ("Trying to Get Along," May 30). Thus, in the midst of their discomfort, they have chosen to lash out with anger and rage, attacking those of us with whom they disagree rather than entering into a dialogue which might lead to a calming of some very emotionally stormy seas.

Since I am the unidentified Reform rabbi, whose recent experience is the subject of Ari's initial report, there are three things that need to be amplified:

1. The Orthodox rabbi with whom I shared a public platform began his tirade against progressive Judaism by telling the audience that his only worship time in a liberal congregation was when he attended a Sunday morning service at Cleveland's Temple when Rabbi Abba Hillel Silver officiated -- that had to be at least 40 years ago! My colleague was unwilling to acknowledge the extent to which Reform Judaism has embraced ritual and ceremony since then.

2. Not only did he denounce me but he declared that "all non-Orthodox Jews are deviants and heathens." That remark leaves little room for discussion and little chance for us to gain harmony and peace.

3. A woman spoke to him, indicating that she had been raised in a small Illinois Reform congregation, that she had moved here, that she and her husband and their children belong to a Reform synagogue in Los Angeles, that they observe the laws of kashrut, they observe Shabbat and all holidays and festivals, regularly study Tanach and perform mitzvot. She asked: "Rabbi, do you respect me?" He replied: "Because of everything that you've just said, there is so much pain in my heart concerning your situation that there is no room in my heart for either respect or love for you."

I just wonder how this particular rabbi and those who agree with him define the term "klal yisrael."

Rabbi Allen I. Freehling, Ph.D. D.D.

University Synagogue

Los Angeles

THE JEWISH JOURNAL welcomes letters from all readers. Letters should be no more than 250 words and we reserve the right to edit for space. All letters must include a signature, valid address and phone number. Pseudonyms and initials will not be used, but names will be withheld on request. Unsolicited manuscripts and other materials should include a self-addressed, stamped envelope in order to be returned.


Publisher, Ed Brennglass

Editor-in chief, Gene Lichtenstein

Editor-at-large, Marlene Adler Marks

Associate editor, Robert Eshman

Assistant editor, Stig Jantz

Copy editor, William Yelles

Senior writer, Naomi Pfefferman

Staff writer, Ruth Stroud

Production coordinator and

&'009;online editor, Sara Eve Roseman

Community editor, Bonnie Trachtenberg

Arts editor, Diane Arieff Zaga

Contributing writers, James David Besser &'009;&'009;(Washington), Larry Derfner (Tel Aviv), Ina &'009;&'009;Friedman (Jerusalem), Linda Feldman, &'009;&'009;Beverly Gray, Joel Kotkin, Rabbi Steven &'009;&'009;Leder, Yehuda Lev, Deborah Berger-Reiss, &'009;&'009;Eric Silver (Jerusalem), Teresa Strasser, Rabbi &'009;Ed Feinstein

Contributing editor, Tom Tugend

Art director, Shelley Adler

Advertising art director, Lionel Ochoa

Members of the corporation,

&'009;Ed Brennglass, Willard Chotiner, Irwin &'009;&'009;Daniels, Irwin Field, Herbert Gelfand, Osias &'009;&'009;Goren, Richard Gunther, Stanley Hirsh, &'009;&'009;Marvin Kristan, Mark Lainer

Legal counsel/ accountants, Leon Katz of &'009;&'009;Tyre, Kamins, Katz and Granoff; Jonathan &'009;&'009;Kirsch of Kirsch and Mitchell/Gerald Block &'009;&'009;of Block, Plant and Eisner


THE JEWISH JOURNAL (ISSN 0888-0468) USPS 468530 is published weekly, every Thursday for $23.50 (out of state add $12.50) by Los Angeles Jewish Publications Inc., a community nonprofit corporation, 3660 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 204, Los Angeles, California 90010. Address all mail to: Jewish Journal, 3660 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 204, Los Angeles, California 90010. Phone 213-738-7778, Fax 213-386-9501. E-mail at Los Angeles Freenet, ab871@lafn.org

© 1997 Los Angeles Jewish Publications Inc.

All rights reserved.

Periodicals Postage Paid at Los Angeles, California.

POSTMASTER: Send address changes to THE JEWISH JOURNAL, 3660 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 204, Los Angeles, California 90010. THE JEWISH JOURNAL is not responsible for unsolicited manuscripts or photographs. They will not be returned unless sender enclosed return postage.

THE JEWISH JOURNAL does not endorse the goods and services advertised in its pages, and it makes no representation as to the kashrut of food products and services in such advertising.

The Jewish Journal is printed

on 100% recycled paper.


For Display Advertising Call

(213) 738-7778

For Classifieds ask for Bob Garcia

For Circulation ask for Myrtle Wells


Tracker Pixel for Entry

COMMENTS

We welcome your feedback.

Privacy Policy

Your information will not be shared or sold without your consent. Get all the details.

Terms of Service

JewishJournal.com has rules for its commenting community.Get all the details.

Publication

JewishJournal.com reserves the right to use your comment in our weekly print publication.

ADVERTISEMENT
PUT YOUR AD HERE